Mental distress predicts divorce over 16 years: the HUNT study

Abstract

BackgroundThe association between mental distress and divorce is well established in the literature. Explanations are commonly classified within two different frameworks; social selection (mentally distressed people are selected out of marriage) and social causation (divorce causes mental distress). Despite a relatively large body of literature on this subject, selection effects are somewhat less studied, and research based on data from both spouses is scarce. The purpose of the present study is to investigate selection effects both at the individual level and the couple level.MethodsThe current study is based on couple-level data from a Norwegian representative sample including 20,233 couples. Long-term selection effects were tested for by means of Cox proportional hazard models, using mental distress in both partners at baseline as predictors of divorce the next 16 years. Three identical sets of analyses were run. The first included the total sample, whereas the second and third excluded couples who divorced within the first 4 or 8 years after baseline, respectively. An interaction term between mental distress in husband and in wife was specified and tested.ResultsHazard of divorce was significantly higher in couples with one mentally distressed partner than in couples with no mental distress in all analyses. There was also a significant interaction effect showing that the hazard of divorce for couples with two mentally distressed partners was higher than for couples with one mentally distressed partner, but lower than what could be expected from the combined main effects of two mentally distressed partners.ConclusionsOur results suggest that mentally distressed individuals are selected out of marriage. We also found support for a couple-level effect in which spouse similarity in mental distress to a certain degree seems to protect against divorce.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12889-015-1662-0) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Long-term effects of mental disorders on marital outcomes in the National Comorbidity Survey ten-year follow-up

“…The results of this study are consistent with past research identifying significant associations between mental disorders and marital outcomes [16,9,27,24]. The nationally representative sampling and longitudinal design of the NCS panel allowed assessment of the contribution of mental disorders to the overall marital outcomes at the population level.…”

Risk factors for suicide in offspring bereaved by sudden parental death from external causes

“…In addition to the loss of a parent, losing a partner and the discontinuation of social and personal life following marital and residence instability may feel as an extra loss and even a traumatic event, resulting in a cumulative effect. Additionally, marital instability and residence instability could be the effect of psychiatric disorders, given that mentally distressed individuals have a higher likelihood of divorce (Idstad et al, 2015). The increased suicide risk associated with life instability in the present study may hence be caused by both low social support and psychiatric disorders.…”

Divorce and Family Structure in Norway: Associations With Adolescent Mental Health

“…114 Additionally, mental distress, poor health, and negative health behaviors predict divorce risk also in Norway. 115,116 Participation in the workforce is strongly encouraged, and subsidized public childcare and generous parental leave rights promote the combination of full-time employment and childcare among both parents. 117 Following a divorce, the custodial parent is supported through tax deductions, cash allowances, and child support, which is enforced by the authorities.…”

“…Poorer financial circumstances and low levels of parental education are associated both with levels of mental health problems among children and increased risk of divorce among adults. 115,235,261 Nonresponse might therefore have had some impact on the results of this thesis. For instance, it is possible that the adolescents most negatively affected by their parents' divorce have had a lower likelihood of participating in the study than their less affected peers.…”