Mentored student project for inculcating research skills

Abstract

Context and setting Most medical schools in India do not emphasise the importance of scientific research skills in the undergraduate medical curriculum despite the fact that it is essential for students to understand scientific methods of critically evaluating the evidence that will assist their decision making during their medical careers. In recognition of this need on the part of medical students, a mentored student project (MSP) programme was implemented in an Indian medical school in 2008 for a batch of medical students. Why the idea was necessary It is essential to inculcate critical thinking and reasoning skills and to develop a positive attitude among medical students towards scientific research from the beginning of their medical careers. As scientific research is rapidly evolving from its status as a largely individual endeavour to that of a highly collaborative, interdisciplinary activity, research training for undergraduate medical students should also inculcate the spirit of teamwork. At present, there is no formal path by which medical students in India can become doctor-scientists or academicians. What was done In the MSP programme, students (n = 113), guided by a teaching faculty member (mentor), were required to undertake a project involving in-depth study of an area of their interest, write a scholarly report and present the work as a poster presentation. To encourage the spirit of teamwork, students were grouped (n = 3-5) and each group was asked to select a research project in the form of a library study, laboratory research, medical records study, case study or field project. To examine the students' perceptions regarding improvements in their research skills after participating in the MSP, a questionnaire consisting of 16 items related to the research skills gained by undertaking projects and the guidance received from the mentor (using a 5-point Likert scale) was developed. Students were requested to indicate their responses on the questionnaire and to describe their previous research experience, if any. Student responses were summarised using percentages. The median grade and interquartile range were reported for each item. A comparison of overall research skills gained with those based on previous research experience was performed using the chisquared test. Evaluation of results and impact The median grade for all items related to improvements in research skills was 4, which indicates that the majority of students felt the MSP had increased their research skills. Type of project and previous research experience were not significantly related to the improvement in overall skills. It was encouraging to find that 80% of the respondents had received appropriate guidance from their mentors. A total of 61% of students agreed that the MSP should be a mandatory requirement for the completion of the MBBS degree at our institution, which suggests that the non-funded MSP programme was successful in fostering a positive attitude towards scientific research. The present study provided scope for the f...

Assessing mentoring: A scoping review of mentoring assessment tools in internal medicine between 1990 and 2019

“…Nine studies assessed the mentee's clinical performance through appraisal of their acquired skills, improvement in "patient care, medical knowledge and interpersonal skills and communications" and development of academic interests, geared towards specific ACGME competencies [79,87,92,101,105,[112][113][114][115]. Four studies evaluated the mentee's research development by assessing their research skills and new collaborations [99][100][101]116].…”