Love and gratitude are emotions that are thought to be key in promoting human flourishing. However, much of the research on these emotions has been conducted in WEIRD samples, limiting our understanding of how these emotions function in other cultural contexts. Here, we tested to what extent there are shared and culturally variable features of love and gratitude. To do so, we examined what elicits these feelings in three cultural contexts that vary in their social orientation and valuation of emotions. European American (N = 99), Chinese (N = 100), and Chilean (N = 97) participants recalled four situations in which they experienced love and gratitude. While certain themes (e.g., Romantic Affection) were universal, there were also differences. European Americans (who tend to be more independent) brought up self-oriented experiences such as pride and awe more than Chinese and Chileans. Conversely, Chileans and Chinese (who tend to be more interdependent) emphasized familial ties and social connections more than European Americans. Importantly, the two interdependent groups diverged. Chinese prioritized the parent-child bond and social obligation more than Chileans. In contrast, Chileans embraced a broader notion of family and valued relational warmth more than Chinese. Implications for the study of culture and emotion are discussed.