A procoagulant effect may occur when enzymatic inhibitors of CYP2C9, 1A2, or 3A4 are therapeutically coadministered with warfarin. To our knowledge, there have been no case reports of such an interaction between warfarin and selegiline. We describe a case of a 49-year-old female who was taking warfarin for prevention of a venous thromboembolism after orthopedic surgery. During routine follow-up, the patient's international normalized ratio (INR) suddenly elevated to 9.0. Her INR had been subtherapeutic for 2 months prior despite escalating doses of warfarin. The only identifiable change to the patient's lifestyle or medications was the initiation of transdermal selegiline 5 days prior to this supratherapeutic INR. Recent laboratory tests revealed no significant abnormalities, with the exception of slightly depressed serum albumin. Her warfarin was held for 2 days, oral phytonadione 2.5 mg was given, and selegiline was held. The Drug Interaction Probability Scale revealed a probable drug-drug interaction between warfarin and selegiline. The likely mechanism of this interaction is selegiline-mediated moderate inhibition of CYP1A2 and weak or competitive inhibition of 2C9 and 3A4. Clinicians should be hypervigilant to this probable drug-drug interaction when initiating either therapy in a patient maintained on the opposing drug.