Composite materials and structural optimization are important research topics in heat transfer enhancement. The current evaluation parameter for the conductive heat transfer capability of composites is effective thermal conductivity (ETC); however, this parameter has not been studied or analyzed for its applicability to different heat transfer models and composite structures. In addition, the optimized composite structures of a specific object will vary when different optimization methods and criteria are employed. Therefore, it is necessary to investigate a suitable method and parameter for evaluating the heat transfer capability of optimized composites under different heat transfer models. Therefore, this study analyzes and summarizes three typical conductive heat transfer models: surface-to-surface (S-to-S), volume-to-surface (V-to-S), and volume-to-volume (V-to-V) models. The equivalent thermal conductivity ( ) is proposed to evaluate the conductive heat transfer capability of topology-optimized composite structures under the three models. A validated simulation method is used to obtain the key parameters for calculating . The influences of the interfacial thermal resistance and size effect on are considered. The results show that the composite structure optimized for the V-to-S and V-to-V models has a value of only 79.4 W m−1 K−1 under the S-to-S model. However, the values are 233.4 W m−1 K−1 and 240.3 W m−1 K−1 under the V-to-S and V-to-V models, respectively, which are approximately 41% greater than those of the in-parallel structure. It can be demonstrated that is more suitable than the ETC for evaluating the V-to-S and V-to-V heat transfer capabilities of composite structures. The proposed can serve as a characteristic parameter that is beneficial for heat transfer analysis and composite structural optimization.