Methane depletion in both polar regions of Uranus inferred from HST/STIS and Keck/NIRC2 observations

Abstract

From Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph (STIS) observations of Uranus in 2012, when good views of its north polar regions were available, we found that the methane volume mixing ratio declined from about 4% at low latitudes to about 2% at 60• N and beyond. This depletion in the north polar region of Uranus in 2012 is similar in magnitude and depth to that found in the south polar regions in 2002. This similarity is remarkable because of the strikingly different appearance of clouds in the two polar regions: we have never seen any obvious signs of convective activity in the south polar region, while the north has been peppered with numerous small clouds thought to be of convective origin. Keck and Hubble Space Telescope imaging observations close to equinox at wavelengths of 1080 nm and 1290 nm, with different sensitivities to methane and hydrogen absorption but similar vertical contribution functions, imply that the depletions were simultaneously present in 2007, and at least their gross character is probably a persistent feature of the Uranus atmosphere. The depletion appears to be mainly restricted to the upper troposphere, with the depth increasing poleward from about 30• N, reaching ∼4 bars at 45• N and perhaps much deeper at 70• N, where it is not well constrained by our observations. The latitudinal variations in degree and depth of the depletions are important constraints on models of meridional circulation. Our observations are qualitatively consistent with previously suggested circulation cells in which rising methane-rich gas at low latitudes is dried out by condensation and sedimentation of methane ice particles as the gas ascends to altitudes above the methane condensation level, then is transported to high latitudes, where it descends and brings down methane depleted gas. Since this cell would seem to inhibit formation of condensation clouds in regions where clouds are actually inferred from spectral modeling, it suggests that sparse localized convective events may be important in cloud formation. A more complex meridional circulation pattern may be necessary to reproduce the observed cloud distribution, but microwave observations appear to be most compatible with a single deep circulation cell. The small-scale latitudinal variations we found in the effective methane mixing ratio between 55• N and 82• N have significant inverse correlations with zonal mean latitudinal variations in cloud reflectivity in near-IR Keck images taken before and after the HST observations. If the CH 4 /H 2 absorption ratio variations are interpreted as local variations in para fraction instead of methane mixing ratio, we find that downwelling correlates with reduced cloud reflectivity. While there has been no significant secular change in the brightness of Uranus at continuum wavelengths between 2002 and 2012, there have been significant changes at wavelengths sensing methane and/or hydrogen absorption, with the southern hemisphere darkening considerably between 2002 and 2012, by ∼25% at mid latitudes near 827 ...

New constraints on the CH4vertical profile in Uranus and Neptune fromHerschelobservations

“…This supports the view (Yelle et al 1989;Moses 2008;Orton et al 2014b, and references therein) that vertical transport depends on latitude, with global circulation effectively decreasing the strength of atmospheric mixing in the stratosphere at high latitudes. This picture could be consistent with the decrease of the upper tropospheric methane from equator to pole (Karkoschka & Tomasko 2009;Sromovsky et al 2014), possibly caused by upward transport of CH 4 -rich air at low latitudes and downward motion of CH 4 -dessicated air over the poles, provided that these cells extend into the stratosphere. Time variability of the convective activity, being more developed near Equinox, is also possible and is supported by the surge of cloud activity near equinox -except at high southern latitudes (Sromovsky et al 2012).…”

“…Despite nearly identical globally averaged tropopause temperatures, stratospheric CH 4 is strongly enhanced in Neptune vs. Uranus (Baines & Hammel 1994). Furthermore, both planets exhibit nonuniformly mixed, subsaturated, and latitudinally variable CH 4 profiles below the 1.5 bar level (Karkoschka & Tomasko 2011;Sromovsky et al 2014). These findings indicate that non-1D and presumably seasonally variable processes are at work, such as upwelling and downwelling convective cells…”

Clouds and aerosols on Uranus: Radiative transfer modeling of spatially-resolved near-infrared Keck spectra

“…Lindal et al (1987) derived temperature and methane profiles for the outer atmosphere of Uranus consistent with radio occultation observations. These profiles, labeled A-F, are characterized by their deep methane mixing ratio which ranges from <2% for profile A to 4% for profile F. Sromovsky et al (2011Sromovsky et al ( , 2014) created additional methane profiles (D1, DE, E1, EF, F1, FG, and G) with associated temperature profiles, consistent with the same observations. The wavelength range we are analyzing is less suited to constraining the deep methane mixing ratio than previous observations; we therefore limit our models to three methane profiles (D1, E1, and F1 with deep volume mixing ratios of 2.22%, 3.20% and 4%) with associated temperature profiles.…”

“…Recently, numerous authors have found that invoking a greater methane abundance over the equator than the poles is required to fit observations (Karkoschka and Tomasko, 2009;Sromovsky et al, 2011Sromovsky et al, , 2014Irwin et al, 2012a;Tice et al, 2013). Sromovsky et al (2011) found they were unable to fit both equatorial and polar spectra with the same vertical distribution of methane, and constructed depleted methane profiles with various depletion degrees and shapes to fit the polar data.…”

The science case for an orbital mission to Uranus: Exploring the origins and evolution of ice giant planets

“…The extreme 98 o obliquity of Uranus subjects the atmosphere to extremes of seasonal forcing, with each pole spending decades in darkness. Despite the bland visible appearance of Uranus from Voyager, recent ground-based observations (e.g., Sromovsky et al, 2007Sromovsky et al, , 2009Sromovsky et al, , 2014de Pater et al, 2011;Fry et al, 2012) have shown the planet to be more dynamically active than previously thought (Fig. 4).…”