“…The fundamental explanation for the difference between our real-time [CH 4 ] measurements (Fig. 3), and the findings of others using static incubation chambers (Keppler et al, 2006;Sanhueza & Donoso, 2006;Terazawa et al, 2007), deserve further investigation. Until experimental evidence for substantial aerobic CH 4 emissions from plants independently confirms the original observations, it may be premature to conclude that high CH 4 concentrations in the tropical troposphere inferred from remote sensing (Frankenberg et al, 2005(Frankenberg et al, , 2006Bergamaschi et al, 2007), and measured above the Venezuelan savanna-forest boundary (Crutzen et al, 2006), and Brazilian rainforests (Carmo et al, 2006;Miller et al, 2007) support the phenomenon.…”