Methodology for developing and evaluating diagnostic tools in Ayurveda – A review

Abstract

Ayurveda has a holistic and person-centric approach towards health and disease, which in turn necessitates consideration of several factors in the process of a diagnostic workup. This concept of personalised diagnosis brings about a high level of variability among the clinicians with respect to their assessment methods and disease diagnosis. Developing and validating diagnostic tools for diseases enumerated in the Ayurvedic classical textbooks can help in standardising the clinical approach, even when attempting to arrive at a patient specific diagnosis. However, diagnostic research is a very less explored area in Ayurveda and there are no established standards for developing and evaluating diagnostic tools. This paper reviews the methodology for the development and validation of diagnostic tools, available in published literature and proposes to integrate this in the field of Ayurveda. The search was conducted on online databases including PubMed, Science Direct, Scopus, and Google scholar, with keywords - ayurvedic diagnosis, diagnostic tool development, validity, reliability, and diagnostic test assessment. The articles were screened based on their comprehensiveness, relevance, and feasibility, and the methodology elaborated in the selected articles was organized into a framework that can be adopted in Ayurveda. We have also tried to examine the methodological challenges of integrating the fundamentals of ayurvedic diagnosis within the current methods of diagnostic research and explored possible solutions. The proposed tool development process involves both qualitative and quantitative components, which may be carried out in three phases that include setting the diagnostic criteria, tool development and validation, and diagnostic test assessment.

A scoping review on the tools for assessment of Agni and its derangements including Grahani dosha

“…Developing a standardized diagnostic tool is an elaborate process, involving a systematic methodology, especially in the case of Ayurveda, owing to the lack of established gold standards for disease diagnosis (18). The initial step of tool development includes a thorough literature review followed by focus group discussions involving experts and the concerned patient population.…”

Baghel Prakash Prognosis Scoring System - Conceptual framework and preliminary psychometric validation

“…Inter-observer variability poses a significant challenge in clinical care and research in Ayurveda. Developing and validating assessment tools can help standardize the clinical approach improving study designs and outcomes [ 10 ].…”