A long-term psychiatric 40 years-old male patient was found dead at 9:00 a.m. in the clinic where he lived. Death was caused by traumatic injuries, which the sanitary staff imputed to a fall. Nurses declared that the patient refused having breakfast, whereas at autopsy the stomach contained 350 g of whitish semifluid material. Using both shotgun and gel-based proteomics, we demonstrated that the chyme contained partly digested milk- and bread-derived proteins, eaten during a recent breakfast. The conflict between evidence and assertions of the attending sanitary staff prompted the Legal Authority to undertake detailed investigations to ascertain facts and possible responsibilities. The herein characterization provides insights in the in vivo mechanisms of gastric breakdown of food proteins in a real meal. β-lactoglobulin was partially resistant to gastric digestion as confirmed by Western blot analysis, in contrast to caseins and wheat gluten proteins, which had been degraded by gastric fluids. In addition to a complex pattern of gastric proteins (e.g., mucin-5AC, pepsin A-3, pepsinogen C, gastric lipase, gastrokine-2, trefoil factors), chyme contained intact proteins and variably sized food-derived polypeptides arising from peptic and nonpeptic proteolytic cleavage as well as heterodimeric disulfide-cross-linked peptides. These findings suggest that the current analytical workflows offer only a partial picture of the real complexity of the human "digestome".