In
this work we studied the host–guest interactions between
confined molecules and zeolites and their relationship with the energies
involved in the reaction of methylation of benzene by methanol in
H-ZSM-5 and H-Beta zeolites employing density functional theory (DFT)
methods and the quantum theory of atoms in molecules. Results show
that the strength of the interactions related to adsorption and coadsorption
processes is higher in the catalyst with the larger cavity; however,
the confinement effects are higher in the smaller zeolite, explaining,
from an electronic viewpoint, the reason why the stabilization energy
is higher in H-ZSM-5 than in H-Beta. The confinement effects of the
catalyst on the confined species for methanol adsorption, benzene
coadsorption, and the formed intermediates dominate this stabilization.
For the transition state (TS), the stability of the TS is achieved
due to the stabilizing effect of the surrounding zeolite framework
on the formed carbocationic species (CH3
+) which
is higher in H-ZSM-5 than in H-Beta. In both TSs the methyl cation
is multicoordinated forming the following H2O···CH3
+···CB concerted bonds.
It is demonstrated that, through the electron density analysis, the
criteria can be defined to discriminate between interactions related
to the confinement effects and the reaction itself (adsorption, coadsorption,
and bond-breaking and bond-forming processes) and, thus, to discriminate
the relative contributions of the degree of confinement to the reaction
energies for two zeolite catalysts with different topologies.