The allelopathic plant Rhus typhina (Rt) has a shallowly distributed root system with a high density of secretory canals, which may allow it to exhibit indirect allelopathic effects through the soil on an understory turf species in a plantation. However, how these effects occur is still not well understood. For this study, the soil from the root zone of Rt was extracted via distilled water, and extracts at different concentrations (25, 50, and 100 g L−1) were used to treat six commonly planted turfgrass species, including Medicago sativa (Ms), Lolium perenne (Lp), Trifolium repens (Tr), Medicago falcata (Mf), Festuca arundinacea (Fa) and Coronilla varia (Cv), during a continuous germination–seedling culture experiment via the sand culture method. The germination, physiological, and growth indicators of the turfgrass seedlings were analyzed. The allelopathic effects of the soil extract at different concentrations on the six receivers were evaluated to provide a scientific basis for managing plantations with multilayer structures. The results indicated that, in general, the extracts of the soil from the root zone of Rt inhibited the germination and seedling growth performance characteristics of the mentioned turfgrasses; the inhibitory effects on Ms, Lp, and Mf increased with increasing concentrations of the Rt soil extracts, whereas those on Fa tended to decrease. In addition, the inhibitory effect on Tr obviously weakened at 50 g·L−1 relative to that at 25 g·L−1, whereas it became more obvious at 100 g·L−1; however, it exhibited the opposite trend for Cv. Generally, Mf and Cv were more sensitive to Rt allelochemicals at relatively low concentrations, and these species should be avoided when planting in Rt plantations at low densities. In contrast, Lp and Tr were more sensitive than those at relatively high concentrations and should be avoided when planting in Rt plantations at high densities.