“…However, inherent thermal instability, high cost, and incompatible processes became critical problems in PSCs. Therefore, inorganic HTLs such as CuO x , MoO x , CoO x , CuCrO x , and NiO x , have been investigated to overcome these shortcomings. − Although many metal oxides are restricted by their insulating properties, NiO HTLs in PSCs are being continuously studied due to their high PCE and stability. − NiO HTLs have shown many advantages such as valence band (VB) matching with most perovskite absorbers, excellent electron blocking, high transparency, and thermal stability. ,, PSCs with NiO as HTLs have been prepared by various synthesis methods such as solution processsing, , sol–gel methods, , electrodeposition, sputtering, , physical laser deposition (PLD), and atomic layer deposition (ALD). , In addition, as postprocesses, two step annealing and reduced graphene oxide (rGO) incorporation have been tried to improve the intrinsic high resistivity of NiO and its hole transfer characteristics. Furthermore, many studies reported the PCE enhancement by increasing the NiO layers’ conductivity by various metal doping, e.g., Zn, Cu, Co, Ag, and Eu. − However, when one considers NiO is a highly stable wide-bandgap semiconductor and it is difficult to generate defect states at low temperature, it proves that Ni 3+ defect states or doped metal states by simple X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) peak deconvolution require further detailed study.…”