“…Mang on the occasion of his 60th birthday Nevertheless, in the majority of subsequent papers these states have been considered to represent the predicted isovector rotational oscillations now generally called scissors modes [3,9,10,11,12,13,14,15]. This view has been questioned by Hamamoto et al [16,17] on the basis of RPA calculations with a schematic force; but the agreement with experimental data was not good enough to make these results particularly convincing.…”