We performed calculations of the in-plane infrared response of underdoped cuprate superconductors to clarify the origin of a characteristic dip feature which occurs in the published experimental spectra of the real part of the in-plane conductivity below an onset temperature T ons considerably higher than T c . We provide several arguments, based on a detailed comparison of our results with the published experimental data, confirming that the dip feature and the related features of the memory function(a peak in M 1 and a kink in M 2 ) are due to superconducting pairing correlations that develop below T ons . In particular, we show that (i) the dip feature, the peak and the kink of the low-temperature experimental data can be almost quantitatively reproduced by calculations based on a model of a d-wave superconductor. The formation of the dip feature in the experimental data below T ons is shown to be analogous to the one occurring in the model spetra below T c . (ii) Calculations based on simple models, for which the dip in the temperature range from T c to T ons is unrelated to superconducting pairing, predict a shift of the onset of the dip at the high-energy side upon entering the superconducting state, that is not observed in the experimental data; (iii) the conductivity data in conjunction with the recent photoemission data (Reber et al 2012 Nat. Phys. 8 606, Reber et al 2013 Phys. Rev. B 87 060506) imply the persistence of the coherence factor characteristic of superconducting pairing correlations in a range of temperatures above T c .− 7 (Y-123) [6].More recently, the interpretation of the T ons scale in terms of a precursor superconductivity has been supported by results obtained by Uykur and coworkers [7]. They address the persistence of the superfluid density above T c and the impact of Zn doping on T ons (T p in the notation of [7]). This interpretation, however, has not yet been commonly accepted. Two reasons are: (i) the c-axis response of Y-123 is a fairly complex quantity due to the specific bilayer structure of this compound. Its interpretation therefore requires a detailed understanding of the c-axis electrodynamics of the bilayer compounds [16][17][18][19][20][21][22][23]. (ii) UD cuprates are known to exhibit ordered phases distinct from superconductivity, in particular, charge modulations have been reported [24,25], that set in at temperatures comparable to T ons . This has fueled speculations that the T ons scale is determined by an order OPEN ACCESS RECEIVED