Migrant women’s health and housing insecurity: an intersectional analysis

Abstract

Purpose This paper presents an analysis of how health intersects with the experience of housing insecurity and homelessness, specifically for migrant women. The authors argue that it is important to understand the specificities of the interplay of these different factors to continue the advancement of our understanding and practice as advocates for health and housing security. Design/methodology/approach An exploratory, qualitative, methodological approach was adopted, using a broad definition of housing insecurity: from absolute homelessness (e.g. residing rough) to invisible homelessness (e.g. couch surfing) to those at risk of homelessness. In total, 26 newcomer (foreign-born women who came to live in Canada during the previous ten years, regardless of their immigration status) women were recruited in Montreal, Canada. Participants were recruited directly through advertisements in public places and in collaboration with community organizations (women’s centers, homeless shelters, crisis centers, domestic violence shelters, immigrant settlement agencies and ethnic associations) and they self-identified as having experienced housing insecurity. Efforts were made to include a diversity of immigrant statuses as well as diversity in ethnicity, race, country of origin, family composition, sexual orientation, age and range of physical and mental ability. Women were engaged in semi-structured, open-ended interviews lasting approximately 1 h. Interviews were conducted in English or French in a location and time of participants’ choosing. Findings The findings are presented around three themes: how health problems instigate and maintain migrant women’s housing insecurity and homelessness; ways in which women’s immigration trajectories and legal status may influence their health experiences; and particular coping strategies that migrant women employ in efforts to maintain or manage their health. The authors conclude with implications of these findings for both policy and practice in relation to migrant women who experience or are at risk of housing insecurity and homelessness. Originality/value Intersections of women experiencing migration and housing insecurity in Canadian contexts have rarely been examined. This paper addresses a gap in the literature in terms of topic and context, but also in terms of sharing the voices of migrant women with direct experience with housing insecurity.

Welcome to Canada: Why Are Family Emergency Shelters ‘Home’ for Recent Newcomers?

“…Focusing specifically on culture or gender would result in a singular view of the newcomer mother experience of homelessness. Other qualitative work in this area highlights the need to examine the intersectional factors of both migration and gender, which combine to affect the vulnerability of newcomer women to housing instability and homelessness [70]. Our approach recognizes the "disadvantage of immigrant women in relation to the dynamics of violence: ethnicity, immigrant status, and interacting gender inequalities" [71], (p. 2).…”

Pandemic precarity and everyday disparity: gendered housing needs in North America

“…Stigma against women experiencing violence is commonly exemplified by "not in my backyard" campaigns against transition houses or by property owners who assume renting to these women will lead to property damage and violence in their neighborhoods (Knowles et al, 2019). Intersectionality matters here: immigrants, Indigenous, women of color, women with children, and those who are LGBTQ2+ report high levels of discrimination in housing searches on the private market, and are also more likely to be evicted (Addis et al, 2009;Hanley et al, 2019;Martin & Walia, 2019;Teixeira, 2006Teixeira, &, 2008Quets et al, 2016).…”

Migration and Economic Inequality in Indonesia: Longitudinal Data Analysis

“…Wood & Kallestrup (2018) and Polillo et al (2018) studies revealed employment status and the quality of health as considerations for migrating. Gender and employment status are also interesting variables to be analyzed in explaining individual considerations to migrate as new information in analyzing migration compared to previous studies (Hanley et al, 2019;Hollis, 2019;Maleku, Kim, & Lee, 2019). The studies revealed that gender differences affected individual decisions in migrating, whether there were specific considerations between men and women in determining the decision to migrate or not.…”

“…(Adams in Indonesia is an interesting part of this study compared to previous research on migration in developing countries. Hanley et al (2019) have researched the health aspects of female migrants and household safety as research variables on migration but did not include aspects of marital status, income level, and education status. Wood & Kallestrup (2018) and Polillo et al (2018) studies revealed employment status and the quality of health as considerations for migrating.…”