Migrants’ Narratives on Urban Governance: A Case from Kolkata, a City of the Global South

Abstract

The paper aims to reveal the politics of urban governance and the associated impact on the lives of disenfranchised migrants. It critically explores the urban governance structure and the nature of practices involved in the cycle of settlement, eviction, resistance and resettlement. The case of Nonadanga, located at the urban margin of Kolkata, India, was explored for this purpose. An ethnographic methodology comprising observation, semi-structured interviews and oral history was adopted for the research. Twelve squatter dwellers and four experts working in Nonadanga and Kolkata were interviewed for this purpose. A three-step data analysis comprising a narrative approach, thematic network analysis and validation was adopted. A critical review of inclusive practices, together with ethnographic survey findings, demonstrates that migrants live in a condition the paper calls “partial rights”, which is a manifestation of the dialectics of inclusiveness practiced by the urban governance structure and derived from the interaction between urban governance structure and migrants’ agency. By analyzing past development trends, the paper outlines possible future scenarios for migrants’ living conditions and discusses their impact on achieving the targeted Sustainable Development Goal 11 for inclusive cities by 2030.

Food Insecurity and Dietary Deprivation: Migrant Households in Nairobi, Kenya

“…UN-Habitat (2014) estimated that 200 million people in Africa or 62% of the region's urban population reside in citycentre slums and peripheral informal settlements. Many migrant households in the city live a precarious existence in these underserviced and overcrowded slums and settlements, unable to secure regular or any employment, and incapable of meeting many basic needs [2][3][4][5]. Poor neighbourhoods in most cities are not only deprived of livelihood opportunities and basic amenities, but disproportionally bear the burden of food insecurity [6][7][8].…”

An Urban Governance Framework for Including Environmental Migrants in Sustainable Cities

“…More generally, creating spaces and participatory processes that link different urban people(s) can support more evidencebased (and inclusive and networked) governance [106], as shown for self-organized groups in three European countries for reducing vulnerability to climate change [145]. Kolkata illustrates that evidence on migrants' knowledge is necessary for successful governance in all these sustainability areas [146].…”

How Can “Community Voices” from Qualitative Research Illuminate Our Understanding of the Implementation of the SDGs? A Scoping Review

“…The authors of these studies argued that if the aspiration of Agenda 2030 is "to leave no one behind", then it is necessary to get into the micro-level to understand how things work and how infrastructure can be improved for the poorest. A critical examination of urban governance and migrant communities in Kolkata [38] suggested there is a long way to go for such aspirations to be realised. Migrant communities were not included in the urban governance process and therefore resorted to extra-legal means to secure their position in the city.…”