Mind the gap: trajectory of cognitive development in young individuals with sickle cell disease: a cross-sectional study

Abstract

Study objectivesCompared to typically developing children and young adults (CYA-TD), those living with Sickle Cell Disease (CYA-SCD) experience more cognitive difficulties, particularly with executive function. Few studies have examined the relative importance of silent cerebral infarction (SCI), haemoglobin and arterial oxygen content on age-related cognitive changes using cross-sectional or longitudinal (developmental trajectory) data. This study presents cohort data from a single timepoint to inform studies with multiple timepoints.MethodsWe compared cross-sectional raw and scaled scores as age-related changes in cognition (trajectories) in CYA-SCD and age-and ethnicity-matched CYA-TD. We also compared cross-sectional age-related changes in cognition (trajectories) in CYA-SCD with and without SCI to CYA-TD. General cognitive abilities were assessed using Wechsler Intelligence Scales, including the Verbal Comprehension Index (VCI) and Perceptual Reasoning Index (PRI) underpinning IQ. Executive function was evaluated using the Delis-Kaplan Executive Function System (D-KEFS) Tower subtest and the Behaviour Rating Inventory of Executive Function (BRIEF) questionnaire. SCI were identified from contemporaneous 3 T MRI; participants with overt stroke were excluded. Recent haemoglobin was available and oxygen saturation (SpO2) was measured on the day of the MRI.ResultsData were available for 120 CYA-SCD [62 male; age = 16.78 ± 4.79 years; 42 (35%) with SCI] and 53 CYA-TD (23 male; age = 17.36 ± 5.16). Compared with CYA-TD, CYA-SCD experienced a delayed onset in VCI and slower rate of development for BRIEF Global Executive Composite, Metacognition Index (MI), and Behaviour Regulation Index. The rate of executive function development for the BRIEF MI differed significantly between CYA-TD and CYA-SCD, with those with SCI showing a 26% delay compared with CYA-TD. For CYA-SCD with SCI, arterial oxygen content explained 22% of the variance in VCI and 37% in PRI, while haemoglobin explained 29% of the variance in PRI.ConclusionAge-related cognitive trajectories of CYA-SCD may not be impaired but may progress more slowly. Longitudinal studies are required, using tests unaffected by practice. In addition to initiation of medical treatment, including measures to improve arterial oxygen content, early cognitive intervention, educational support, and delivery of extracurricular activities could support cognitive development for CYA-SCD.

Decline in Processing Speed Tells Only Half the Story: Developmental Delay in Children Living with Sickle Cell Disease

“…Due to different assessment tools (e.g., WPPSI and WISC) being used for children of different ages (within and across timepoints), we could not explore the utility of raw score data and are limited in the conclusions we can draw about why a decline in standardised scores was observed. This highlights the importance of utilising assessment tools which cover multiple age ranges and can be used longitudinally with limited practice effects [ 28 ].…”

“…Emerging research indicates that young people with SCD show lower PSI scores compared to demographically matched controls, with either consistency or decline in standardised performance with age examined cross-sectionally [ 10 , 28 ]. However, most research on cognition in SCD has been cross-sectional and focused on assessing intelligence (IQ) [ 29 ] and EF [ 30 ].…”