Understanding the rheology behavior of non-Newtonian mine paste backfill is critical to ensure its flowability in the pipeline distribution system. Several rheology measurements methods for paste backfill have been proposed in the literature to quantify the rheology properties. However, there is no definite conclusion on the best measurement method to correctly predict pressure loss in the paste backfill pipeline system with a high solid concentration. This study addresses the issue by comparing several rheology measurements techniques, i.e., coaxial rheometer with various configurations, vane viscometer, and slump and pipe loop tests, with regard to Bingham yield stress, Bingham plastic viscosity, and pressure loss using statistical analysis. The paste backfill samples are prepared from two different mine tailings: finer and coarser particles. The pressure loss from the pipe loop test along with Buckingham-Reiner transformation using the Darcy-Weisbach equation are used as reference properties. The results suggest that a simple slump test can accurately predict the Bingham yield stress for coarser tailing. At the same time, a coaxial rheometer with MVDIN cup is found to predict the Bingham paste properties accurately for finer tailing.