The devastating impact of a circumflex coronary artery (CX) injury during mitral valve (MV) surgery is well reported. Despite significant improvements in preoperative risk assessment, intraoperative diagnosis and perioperative treatment strategies of CX injury during MV surgery, recent reports re-emphasize the variability in presentation, the unpredictable mechanisms of injury and the conflicting evidence regarding perioperative management. The progressive transition from conventional sternotomy access to minimally invasive surgical and transcatheter (TC) interventions for MV disease are associated with significant learning curves and require additional single-shaft and robotic console suture manipulation skills with special attentiveness to the potential risk of CX injury. The introduction of hybrid theatres that facilitate single stage surgical and TC interventions also provides new intraoperative diagnostic and therapeutic options without transporting unstable patients for percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) assessment. By utilizing a MeSH terms-based PubMed search, a total of 89 patients with CX injury that occurred during MV surgery was identified from 49 reports between 1967 and 2022. MV surgery was performed by conventional sternotomy (n = 76, 85.4%), endoscopic (n = 12, 13.4%) and robotic access (n = 1, 1.1%), with 35 injuries (39.3%) resulting in total CX occlusion. Rescue PCI was utilized in 40 patients (44.9%). This manuscript provides a systematic overview of all available historic and contemporary reports on CX injury during MV surgery, outlines recent refinements in CX injury mechanisms, describes current MV surgery associated CX injury prevention and diagnosis and treatment strategies and highlights important MV procedural aspects that may minimize the risk and consequences of CX injury.