“…Since the Aitken mode is still present in the droplet residuals and therefore must have activated prior to sampling, possible explanations are that either (1) the peak SS at the onset of the cloud formation was often higher than 1%, which is within the possible range from model simulations presented in Bulatovic et al (2021), or, more likely, (2) the water uptake on those particles is generally too slow for droplet activation to occur in the short residence time of the particles in the CCNC cloud chamber, as previously suggested by Leck and Svensson (2015), or (3) that the drying process evaporated not only water, but also a fraction of the solute, which would affect the residuals ability to reactivate into a droplet, as suggested by Rissler et al (2023). The presence of an Aitken mode in the residuals is unlikely due to sampling artifacts by the GCVI, such as droplet break up, particle capture by wake effect, or ice crystal shattering, which start occurring at larger crystal diameters than those sampled in these events, as extensively discussed in Karlsson et al (2021Karlsson et al ( , 2022.…”