Oxidative stress (an overproduction of reactive oxygen species in relation to defense mechanisms) may restrict investment in life history traits, such as growth, reproduction, lifespan, and the production of sexual signals to attract mates. The constraint on sexual signaling by oxidative stress is of particular interest because it has been proposed as a mechanism ensuring that only good-quality males produce the most attractive sexual signals. Despite these predictions, evidence supporting this theory is, at best, equivocal. We used a superoxide dismutase knockout mouse to demonstrate that oxidative stress directly impairs investment in morphological (preputial glands) and molecular (major urinary proteins) components of olfactory signaling essential for mate attraction. By maintaining males in a much more competitive environment than usual for mouse laboratory experiments, we also revealed a range of phenotypes of superoxide dismutase deficiency not observed in previous studies of this mouse model. This range included impaired bioenergetic function, which was undetectable in the control environment of this study. We urge further examination of model organisms in seminatural conditions and more competitive laboratory environments, as important phenotypes can be exposed under these more demanding conditions.L ife history theory is based on the premise that physiological constraints limit investment in life history components. These constraints are expected to generate the negative correlations commonly observed between these traits on an interspecies level (1). Within species, individuals also differ in their capacity to invest in different traits (2), although the physiological causes of this variation remain largely elusive.Oxidative stress occurs as a consequence of an overproduction of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in relation to defense mechanisms (3). Because ROS are produced as a by-product of oxidative phosphorylation, investment in energetically demanding life history traits has been predicted to increase oxidative stress, which may then constrain investment in other areas (4, 5). Ecological research in wild animals has provided correlative evidence for a link between oxidative stress and investment in traits, such as growth (6), reproduction (7,8), and lifespan (7). Early evidence linking oxidative stress to variation in lifespan within (9) and between species (10) led to the development of genetically modified antioxidant enzyme knockout animals, allowing precise tests of the effects of these pathways on lifespan under controlled laboratory conditions (11). These tests concluded that oxidative stress does not play a major role in governing the lifespan of laboratory animals (11).As in the case of lifespan, sexual signals show considerable among-individual variation and can correlate with oxidative stress. Sexual signals are often condition-dependent in expression, such that only good-quality signalers express the largest or most elaborate sexual signals (12). These signaling systems only evolve and rem...