Mixed methods research in tobacco control with youth and young adults: A methodological review of current strategies

Abstract

IntroductionTobacco use among young people is a complex and serious global dilemma that demands innovative and diverse research approaches. The purpose of this methodological review was to examine the current use of mixed methods research in tobacco control with youth and young adult populations and to develop practical recommendations for tobacco control researchers interested in this methodology.MethodsUsing PubMed, we searched five peer-reviewed journals that publish tobacco control empirical literature for the use of mixed methods research to study young populations, age 12–25 years. Our team analyzed the features of each article in terms of tobacco control topic, population, youth engagement strategies, and several essential elements of mixed methods research.ResultsWe identified 23 mixed methods studies published by authors from five different countries reported between 2004 and 2015. These 23 articles examined various topics that included tobacco use behavior, tobacco marketing and branding, and cessation among youth and young adults. The most common mixed methods approach was variations of the concurrent design in which the qualitative and quantitative strands were administered at the same time and given equal priority. This review documented several innovative applications of mixed methods research as well as challenges in the reporting of the complex research designs.ConclusionsThe use of mixed methods research in tobacco control has great potential for advancing the understanding of complex behavioral and sociocultural issues for all groups, especially youth and young adults.

A Methodological Review of Mixed Methods Research in Palliative and End-of-Life Care (2014–2019)

“…In line with findings reported in recent reviews [8,26,34], many articles reported a convergent design and cited complementarity as the main rationale for mixing methods. In these studies, the findings of the quantitative and the qualitative components were used to enrich or elaborate on the findings of the other component or to provide further insights.…”

“…We examined the relationship between type of design and study purpose since these two elements are closely associated, as frequently stated in the mixed methods literature [20,26]. Table 5 shows a significant relationship (p < 0.001) between the study purpose and the type of mixed methods used: while convergent and explanatory sequential designs were used mainly for evaluating interventions or investigating research topics in palliative care, exploratory sequential, and multistage designs were generally employed to develop a tool, a quantitative instrument, or an intervention.…”

“…Palliative care and other health researchers face important challenges when reporting mixed methods research. These include the length limitations of journals [26], practitioners' lack of familiarity with mixed methods research [4], the complexity of reporting integration [21], and authors' lack of knowledge of reporting guidelines [35].…”

Determinants of smokeless tobacco use in India

“…Tobacco use is not restricted to individual's behaviour but is a multifaceted process contributed by a varied range of factors such as social, environmental, psychological and the genetic factors which are linked to the tobacco use 15 . The determinants associated with SLT consumption include gender, wealth index (inverse association) and association with scheduled tribe 16 .…”

Development and psychometric properties of the Mothers' Sex Education Ability Questionnaire (SEDA)

“…This was a methodological study [21] and was conducted to design a questionnaire for assessing mothers' sex education ability to preschool children in Iran, in 2018. In this study, only interviews with mothers were used due to the fact that in Iran mothers are culturally responsible for the education of children, although the new educational evidence in the world emphasizes the responsibility of parents in educating children.…”