We consider binary polymer blends where the energetic interactions
between the three
different pairs of monomers are not equal to each other. From
computer simulations in the isothermal−isobaric ensemble, we show that these disparate energetic interactions
yield different packing behavior
even at the level of the pure components. This results in the pure
materials having unequal densities
and cohesive energies. In the context of mixtures we have
considered two cases. In the system termed
“attractive” we have employed Lennard−Jones interactions which
favor the formation of dissimilar 1−2
contacts. The residual chemical potential changes on mixing for
both components, independently, appear
to vary parabolically with system composition. If one chose to
model these results with the Flory model
[or alternately, the polymer analog of the regular solution theory],
then the chemical potential changes
on mixing for each component would appear to be describable by a
composition independent value of the
χ parameter. However, the effective χ values derived from the
two components are not equivalent. Since
this finding violates thermodynamic consistency, it implies that the
effective single χ parameter
characterizing the free energy of mixing must be composition dependent.
Similar results were obtained
in the case of a “nominally athermal” blend, where the 1−2
interaction energy was selected to yield χ =
0 if the blend followed the Flory assumptions of incompressibility and
randomly mixed chain segments.
We show that these results can be explained on the basis of
energetic effects and nonrandom mixing
which is triggered by differences in the packing behavior of the pure
components. Finally, this packing
disparity also causes polymer blends with nominal χ = 0 in terms of
the Flory lattice definition to phase
separate. This phenomenon is a consequence of the coupling between
packing and energetic interactions
which yields an unfavorable enthalpy change on mixing. We conclude
by emphasizing, in agreement
with past theoretical calculations, the importance of packing effects
in describing the thermodynamics of
polymer systems, an issue which must be included if an improved
description of polymer thermodynamics
is to be achieved.