Abstract. The recent determination of the charged πN N coupling constant, g π ± , by the Uppsala Neutron Research Group implies that there may be considerable charge-splitting of the pion coupling constant. We investigate the consequences of this for the charge-independence breaking (CIB) of the 1 S 0 scattering length, ∆a CIB . We find that ∆a CIB depends sensitively on the difference between g π ± and the neutral πN N coupling constant, g π 0 . Moreover, if g 2 π ± is only about 3% larger than g 2 π 0 , then the established theoretical explanation of ∆a CIB (in terms of pion mass splitting) is completely wiped out.