“…After years of experimental searches, several promising candidates finally emerged, including the "perfect" spin-1 2 kagome lattice herbertsmithite ZnCu 3 ͑OH͒ 6 Cl 2 , which shows no signs of magnetic ordering down to a temperature of 50 mK, despite having a nearestneighbor antiferromagnetic exchange J Ϸ 190 K. [1][2][3] Ever since the successful synthesis of herbertsmithite, 4 a host of experimental techniques have been applied to study the material, including thermodynamic measurements, 1,3,5,6 neutron diffraction, 1,7 NMR, 3,8,9 and SR. 2,3 Unfortunately, the experimental results accumulated thus far are still insufficient to determine if the material is truly a quantum spin liquid. In particular, the valence-bond solid ͑VBS͒ state proposed in Refs.…”