The LHCb collaboration has recently discovered three pentaquark-like states-the P c ð4312Þ, P c ð4440Þ and P c ð4457Þ-close to theDΣ c and theD Ã Σ c meson-baryon thresholds. The standard interpretation is that they are heavy antimeson-baryon molecules. Their quantum numbers have not been determined yet, which implies two possibilities for the P c ð4440Þ and P c ð4457Þ: J P ¼ 1 2 − and J P ¼ 3 2 −. The preferred interpretation within a contact-range effective field theory is that the P c ð4440Þ is the J P ¼ 1 2 − molecule, while the P c ð4457Þ is the J P ¼ 3 2 − one. Here we show that when the one pion exchange potential between the heavy antimeson and heavy baryon is taken into account, this conclusion changes, with the contrary identification being as likely as the original one. The identification is however cutoff dependent, which suggests that improvements of the present description (e.g., the inclusion of subleading order corrections, like two-pion exchanges) are necessary in order to disambiguate the spectroscopy of the molecular pentaquarks.