Mobile Phone Ownership Is Not a Serious Barrier to Participation in Studies: Descriptive Study

Abstract

BackgroundRather than providing participants with study-specific data collection devices, their personal mobile phones are increasingly being used as a means for collecting geolocation and ecological momentary assessment (EMA) data in public health research.ObjectiveThe purpose of this study was to (1) describe the sociodemographic characteristics of respondents to an online survey screener assessing eligibility to participate in a mixed methods study collecting geolocation and EMA data via the participants’ personal mobile phones, and (2) examine how eligibility criteria requiring mobile phone ownership and an unlimited text messaging plan affected participant inclusion.MethodsAdult (≥18 years) daily smokers were recruited via public advertisements, free weekly newspapers, printed flyers, and word of mouth. An online survey screener was used as the initial method of determining eligibility for study participation. The survey screened for twenty-eight inclusion criteria grouped into three categories, which included (1) cell phone use, (2) tobacco use, and (3) additional criteriaResultsA total of 1003 individuals completed the online screener. Respondents were predominantly African American (605/1003, 60.3%) (60.4%), male (514/1003, 51.3%), and had a median age of 35 years (IQR 26-50). Nearly 50% (496/1003, 49.5%) were unemployed. Most smoked menthol cigarettes (699/1003, 69.7%), and had a median smoking history of 11 years (IQR 5-21). The majority owned a mobile phone (739/1003, 73.7%), could install apps (86.8%), used their mobile phone daily (89.5%), and had an unlimited text messaging plan (871/1003, 86.8%). Of those who completed the online screener, 302 were eligible to participate in the study; 163 were eligible after rescreening, and 117 were enrolled in the study. Compared to employed individuals, a significantly greater proportion of those who were unemployed were ineligible for the study based on mobile phone inclusion criteria (P<.001); yet, 46.4% (333/717) of the individuals who were unemployed met all mobile phone inclusion criteria.ConclusionsInclusion criteria requiring participants to use their personal mobile phones for data collection was not a major barrier to study participation for most respondents who completed the online screener, including those who were unemployed.Trial RegistrationClinicalTrials.gov NCT02261363; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02261363 (Archived by WebCite at http://www.webcitation.org/6wOmDluSt)

Depression as a moderator of the prospective relationship between mood and smoking.

“…First, the study utilized an online screener for initial participant recruitment and the protocol required participants to have an iPhone or Android smartphone, which may have been a barrier to enrollment for individuals lacking Internet access and/or the requirement cellphone, respectively. However, approximately 72% individuals who were screened met all smartphone inclusion criteria, suggesting that smartphone ownership was not a major barrier to study participation for individuals with Internet access (Harvey et al, 2018).…”

Adolescents’ Online Coping: When Less Is More but None Is Worse

“…Studies have shown that youths from low socioeconomic status (SES) backgrounds are more likely to own a mobile phone (e.g., Byun et al, 2013), to access their phones more frequently (Lenhart, 2015), and in general to spend more time on their phones (Thomas et al, 2010) relative to those from higher SES contexts. This intersection of increased stress exposure and technological access (e.g., Harvey et al, 2018) makes the possible benefits of online coping especially compelling.…”

Requiring smartphone ownership for mHealth interventions: who could be left out?

“…The authors found that none of the demographics they used to screen patients were significantly associated with smartphone ownership. However, participants were recruited by an online screener, which could itself exclude individuals who do not own a smartphone [11]. Studies that include participants based on their disease status and assess smartphone ownership are needed to determine which patients could be excluded from mHealth interventions if they are required to use their own smartphone.…”