Mobility assessment of a rural population in the Netherlands using GPS measurements

Abstract

BackgroundThe home address is a common spatial proxy for exposure assessment in epidemiological studies but mobility may introduce exposure misclassification. Mobility can be assessed using self-reports or objectively measured using GPS logging but self-reports may not assess the same information as measured mobility. We aimed to assess mobility patterns of a rural population in the Netherlands using GPS measurements and self-reports and to compare GPS measured to self-reported data, and to evaluate correlates of differences in mobility patterns.MethodIn total 870 participants filled in a questionnaire regarding their transport modes and carried a GPS-logger for 7 consecutive days. Transport modes were assigned to GPS-tracks based on speed patterns. Correlates of measured mobility data were evaluated using multiple linear regression. We calculated walking, biking and motorised transport durations based on GPS and self-reported data and compared outcomes. We used Cohen’s kappa analyses to compare categorised self-reported and GPS measured data for time spent outdoors.ResultsSelf-reported time spent walking and biking was strongly overestimated when compared to GPS measurements. Participants estimated their time spent in motorised transport accurately. Several variables were associated with differences in mobility patterns, we found for instance that obese people (BMI > 30 kg/m2) spent less time in non-motorised transport (GMR 0.69–0.74) and people with COPD tended to travel longer distances from home in motorised transport (GMR 1.42–1.51).ConclusionsIf time spent walking outdoors and biking is relevant for the exposure to environmental factors, then relying on the home address as a proxy for exposure location may introduce misclassification. In addition, this misclassification is potentially differential, and specific groups of people will show stronger misclassification of exposure than others. Performing GPS measurements and identifying explanatory factors of mobility patterns may assist in regression calibration of self-reports in other studies.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12942-017-0103-y) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

A systematic knowledge synthesis on the spatial dimensions of Q fever epidemics

“…Information on cattle trade was used for this, unfortunately obtaining data on human movement patterns is more complicated. Klous et al (2017) assessed mobility by means of GPS data collected in 2014-2016 of participants living in the region affected most by Q fever during the epidemic. It is expected that in the near future data on movement patterns will contribute to improved risk assessment.…”

Transport-related walking among young adults: when and why?

“…Conventionally, studies on urban form and active travel have relied on self-report questionnaires or travel diaries to capture active travel patterns [24,29]. The data collected with such instruments are subject to recall bias and bias from misclassification of activities reported by participants [30,31]. Short trips, often walking trips under 10 min, are usually missing in the data collected by these instruments [32].…”

“…This is especially important as the possibility of mapping active travel to urban form in diverse settings enables us to better understand people's active travel patterns [37]. The GPS-enabled technology allows for the objective measurement of a person's movements at a fine-grained level of geographic and temporal detail, and in doing so, it mitigates the issues associated with self-report biases and lack of spatial details [31,38]. The widespread use of smartphones has been shown to dramatically simplify the data collection process [38,39], allowing for largescale studies of people's PA and health behaviours [30].…”

“…An understanding of such patterns can inform urban design and indicate where PA-facilitating urban form features such as sidewalks can have the greatest potential to impact population health. We build upon recent work (e.g., [30,31,37,38,40]) by automatically collecting continuous data on young people's active travel behaviour, and exploring the timing and location of transport-related walking for our sample. We identify eight main activity nodes where transport-related walking originates from or leads to, including education, home, work, shopping, health/wellbeing, eat/drink, changing mode and other.…”

Mapping Rural Road Networks from Global Positioning System (GPS) Trajectories of Motorcycle Taxis in Sigomre Area, Siaya County, Kenya

“…In rural areas, data from GPS data loggers have been used to assess mobility patterns and to calibrate the data from self-reports [46]. In a related study, GPS data loggers were used to assess the mobility pattern of residents of a rural area in Zambia and to evaluate the impact of the mobility on the spread of malaria [47].…”