DNA methylation and histone modifications mediate the long-term maintenance of gene expression states and are believed to be established in an all-or-none manner, allowing cells to maintain memory of silenced and active gene states. Here, we investigate whether these modifications can also enable memory of any gene expression level, and thus can equip cells with "analog memory". Surprisingly, we find that cells can maintain intermediate gene expression levels by grades of DNA methylation that remain stable over time. Our nucleosome modification model recapitulates this result when H3K9me3 does not catalyze the recruitment of DNA methylation and the remaining DNA methylation kinetics are slow. The observation that long-term memory is possible for any gene expression level deepens our understanding of epigenetic cell memory and potentially broadens our view of what constitutes a cell type.