The class G oil well cement is a type of special cement that can be subjected to a high temperature formation environment. It was found that the class G cement tail slurry with a low polycarboxylic retarder dosage (usually ≤1% by weight of cement) was more prone to cause the abnormal gelation phenomenon (AGP) than the lead slurry with a high retarder dosage at a high temperature (usually when T ≥ 120 °C). This study aimed at the occurrence mechanism of this unfavorable phenomenon that seriously endangers the cementing security. Results showed that the abnormal gelatinous region underwent premature hydration; namely, the calcium hydroxide and calcium silicate hydrate (C−S−H) content were all higher than the nongelatinous region, while the copolymer content was the opposite. Correspondingly, the theory of "premature hydration and crystal nucleation" was proposed to explain the abnormal gelation mechanism of a cementing tail slurry with an insufficient retarder dosage. Furthermore, a novel functionalized copolymer retarder "PAIANS" was synthesized to alleviate the AGP.