Moderating role of cynicism about organizational change between authentic leadership and commitment to change in Pakistani public sector hospitals

Abstract

Purpose This study aims to explore the moderating role of cynicism about change in the positive relationship between authentic leadership and employee commitment to change. Design/methodology/approach This study used an exploratory research design with deductive approach to invite responses of doctors, nurses and para medical staff of public sector district hospitals, set to be privatized, on structured close-ended questionnaires. Data gathered from four hospitals chosen because they were undergoing restructuring that facilitated the testing of our propositions were analyzed through structural equation modeling using AMOS. A total of 271 usable responses (response rate of 65 per cent) were analyzed. Interaction and simple slope tests were applied to test moderating effects. Findings Results indicate that authentic leadership is positively related to commitment to change. Cynicism about change moderated this positive relationship such that a high level of authentic leadership has a stronger impact on commitment to change when cynicism is low rather than when cynicism is high. Practical implications Results show that in Pakistani hospitals undergoing restructuring, leaders who use authentic leadership will have followers who are more committed to enacting the planned changes, but this effect is magnified if followers are not cynical about the change. Thus, regulators of public sector hospitals may benefit from this study by developing authenticity in hospital leaders to mitigate cynicism about and enhance their commitment to change. Originality/value This study is the first which has explored relationships among cynicism about change, authentic leadership and commitment to change in a privatization context of Pakistan. Findings should be tested in other cultural contexts to determine generalizability.

Fear Destroys the Ability to Trust: Impact on Employee Engagement during Structural Change in Telecommunication Sector of Pakistan

“…Another concern during structural change is employees' trust in change leadership. As stated earlier, structural changes are prone to employee cynicism and uncertainty, thus may lead to negative behaviors (Bakari et al, 2019;Brown & Cregan, 2008). However, role of trust in change leadership in this case is paramount which ultimately effect the employee attitude towards change and the degree of their willingness to support the change.…”

“…Organizations face variety of changes, however structural change has marked the new digital realities of the twenty first century (Malik & Garg, 2020). Structural changes tend to alter ways of doing things thus creating an uncertain environment where employees feel unsafe and cynical (Bakari, Hunjra, Jaros, & Khoso, 2019). In order to implement change successfully and sustain the competitive edge in the market, organizations demand highly engaged workforce with lower levels of change related uncertainties and cordial leader member relations (Choi, 2011).…”

Managing Organizational Inertia: Indonesian Family Business Perspective

“…Cynicism is essentially the end result of a preceding process ( Wanous et al, 2004 ; Grama and Todericiu, 2016 ; Schraeder et al, 2016 ; Bakari et al, 2019 ). According to Dean et al (1998) , there are five fundamental conceptualizations of cynicism: personality cynicism, societal or institutional cynicism, occupational cynicism, employee cynicism, and skepticism about organizational transformation.…”

“…Perhaps executives and managers believe they have a better understanding of upcoming plans and decision-making processes ( Reichers et al, 1997 ). According to a previous empirical study conducted by ( Stanley et al, 2005 ; Qian and Daniels, 2008 ; Grama and Todericiu, 2016 ; Bakari et al, 2019 ; Scott and Zweig, 2020 ), cynicism about organizational change is likely caused by a lack of general knowledge about what was happening in the workplace, a lack of communication and respect from the supervisor or union representative, a negative disposition, and a lack of opportunity for meaningful participation in decision-making.…”

Determinants of Employees’ Openness to Change: Insights from Service and Manufacturing Sectors of Pakistan

“…Relational transparency is vital in developing trust when it has disintegrated, particularly in reestablishing trust (Basit, 2020). Bakari et al (2019) attempted to discover the link between authentic leadership and employee commitment. Authentic leadership is connected to commitment to change and brings positive change in employees' commitment when their organization undergoes change or rebuilding process.…”