Moderating role of Shariah committee quality on relationship between board of directors effectiveness and the performance of Malaysian Takaful

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this study is to examine the effect of Board of Directors Effectiveness (BODE) on the performance of Malaysian Takaful companies licensed by the Central Bank of Malaysia. In addition, the study investigates the moderating effect of Shariah Committee Quality (SCQ) on the relationship between BODE and companies’ performance. Design/methodology/approach This study uses a sample of 11 Malaysian Takaful companies during the period of 2010-2017. While BDE and SCQ are measured using indices, performance is proxied using ROA and ROE. A panel fixed effect regression analysis is used to test the impact of the BDE on the financial performance of Malaysian Takaful companies and the moderator role of SCQ. Findings The main finding of this study shows a positive association between BDE and performance. More specifically, boards with a high presence of independent, Muslim and female directors positively contribute to the performance of Malaysian Takaful companies. Another interesting finding is related to the positive moderating effect of SCQ on the relationship between BDE and performance. This result indicates that a high level of SCQ combined with a high level of board effectiveness improve performance. Practical implications The finding is of great importance to stakeholders and policymakers to improve their board effectiveness and the quality of the Shariah committee to reduce agency costs and to improve the performance of Malaysian Takaful companies. Originality/value This study adds to the prior literature by investigating for the first time the relationship between BDE and performance and the interaction effect of SCQ on the performance of Malaysian Takaful companies.

Guest editorial: Sustainability reporting in different institutional and regulatory environments

“…The results indicated that the compulsory risk disclosure practices positively affect the volatility of stock returns for insurance companies in the UK, but not for Canadian companies. In the same context, Eldaia et al (2022) study found that governance and the efficiency of the board of directors affect the performance of Malaysian companies. The study of Al-Ajmi et al (2022), which included two parts.…”

Evaluation of management soundness of Takaful industry in selected countries

“…Irrespective of the type of takaful, the need for soundness in takaful management is crucial. Eldaia et al (2022) used data from 2010 to 2019 to examine the performance effectiveness of the board of directors of takaful companies in Malaysia. The findings revealed that a high level of Shariah Committee Quality and a high level of board effectiveness contribute to the high-performance level of takaful companies.…”

Investigating earnings management practices and the role of the board and committees in emerging markets: Evidence from Malaysian public companies

“…The board of directors is responsible for overseeing and regulating manager behavior as one of the CG mechanisms to make sure they work in the best interests of shareholders and safeguard their investment (Metawee, 2013; Vasilakopoulos et al., 2018). The board is also responsible for approving the firm's strategy, creating directing policy, selecting, managing, and compensating senior executives, as well as ensuring the firm's accountability to its related parties (Alhossini et al., 2021; Eldaia et al., 2023; Rahman et al., 2019). They set the course and exercise the proper control to make sure the business is run in a way that meets the expectations of society and its stakeholders (Gerged et al., 2021; Gull et al., 2018).…”

“…With the globalization of businesses and financial markets, there has been a strong demand for high-quality information from business corporations throughout countries so that investors can compare risk and return across markets, placing higher significance on good CG mechanism. Nevertheless, previous literatures tended to explain audit and board composition separately although these two components work together synergistically in ensuring CG effectiveness (Al-Haddad & Whittington, 2019;Alhossini et al, 2021;Eldaia et al, 2023;Gerged et al, 2021;Hernawati, 2021;Inaam & Khamoussi, 2016;Mardjono & Chen, 2020;Zalata et al, 2018Zalata et al, , 2022Zehri & Zgarni, 2020). These studies indicate a gap in the current literature.…”