Modes of Large-Scale Brain Network Organization during Threat Processing and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Symptom Reduction during TF-CBT among Adolescent Girls

Abstract

Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is often chronic and disabling across the lifespan. The gold standard treatment for adolescent PTSD is Trauma-Focused Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy (TF-CBT), though treatment response is variable and mediating neural mechanisms are not well understood. Here, we test whether PTSD symptom reduction during TF-CBT is associated with individual differences in large-scale brain network organization during emotion processing. Twenty adolescent girls, aged 11–16, with PTSD related to assaultive violence completed a 12-session protocol of TF-CBT. Participants completed an emotion processing task, in which neutral and fearful facial expressions were presented either overtly or covertly during 3T fMRI, before and after treatment. Analyses focused on characterizing network properties of modularity, assortativity, and global efficiency within an 824 region-of-interest brain parcellation separately during each of the task blocks using weighted functional connectivity matrices. We similarly analyzed an existing dataset of healthy adolescent girls undergoing an identical emotion processing task to characterize normative network organization. Pre-treatment individual differences in modularity, assortativity, and global efficiency during covert fear vs neutral blocks predicted PTSD symptom reduction. Patients who responded better to treatment had greater network modularity and assortativity but lesser efficiency, a pattern that closely resembled the control participants. At a group level, greater symptom reduction was associated with greater pre-to-post-treatment increases in network assortativity and modularity, but this was more pronounced among participants with less symptom improvement. The results support the hypothesis that modularized and resilient brain organization during emotion processing operate as mechanisms enabling symptom reduction during TF-CBT.

Neural Correlates of Psychotherapeutic Treatment of Post-traumatic Stress Disorder: A Systematic Literature Review

“…Decreased pre-to-post-treatment activity in “emotional brain areas” like the insula and amygdala was more pronounced in within-group analyses (37, 53) and compared to patients of the waitlist control group (35, 40). Those findings underscore the importance of taking into consideration the control group applied when interpreting data of treatment studies.…”

Determining the Hierarchical Architecture of the Human Brain Using Subject-Level Clustering of Functional Networks

“…In the brain, these communities are known to represent subsystems and mediate distinct neurophysiological functions (e.g., the brain's visual subnetwork) Power et al, 2011;Cole et al, 2014). Moreover, this scale is highly sensitive to disease, where several psychiatric disorders have shown selective disruption in particular brain communities (Alexander-Bloch et al, 2012;Akiki et al, 2017Akiki et al, , 2018Menon, 2011;Cisler et al, 2016). This apparent importance has prompted interest in this line of investigation; while a vast wealth of knowledge has been gained from these efforts, several methodological pitfalls remain.…”

Functional Brain Network Changes Following Use of an Allostatic, Closed‐Loop, Acoustic Stimulation Neurotechnology for Military‐Related Traumatic Stress

“…8 DMN changes may be related to the dissociative features of PTSD, including the loss of a stable and coherent sense of the self. Altered CEN connectivity is also shown in PTSD 2,13 and may contribute to difficulty for top down tasks of cognitive control including those related to working memory or emotional regulation. SN alterations in PTSD 9,10,14 may produce perceptions of stimuli (internal or external) that entail maladaptive modes of threat sensitivity, and may interfere with switching between the CEN and DMN, 2,8,10 leading to inefficient discrimination between task-relevant and task-irrelevant behaviors.…”