A fragment of the human prion protein spanning residues 106-126 (PrP106-126) recapitulates many essential properties of the disease-causing protein such as amyloidogenicity and cytotoxicity. PrP106-126 has an amphipathic characteristic that resembles many antimicrobial peptides (AMPs). Therefore, the toxic effect of PrP106-126 could arise from a direct association of monomeric peptides with membrane matrix. Several experimental approaches are employed to scrutinize the impacts of monomeric PrP106-126 on model lipid membranes. Porous defects in planar bilayers are observed by using solution atomic force microscopy. Adding cholesterol does not impede defect formation. Force spectroscopy experiment shows that PrP106-126 reduces Young’s modulus of planar lipid bilayers. We use Raman microspectroscopy to study the effect of PrP106-126 on lipid vibrational dynamics. For phosphatidylcholine lipids, PrP106-126 disorders the intra-chain conformation, while the inter-chain interaction is not altered; for phosphatidylethanolamine lipids, PrP106-126 increases the inter-chain interaction, while the intra-chain conformational order remains similar. We explain the observed differences by considering different modes of peptide insertion. Finally, electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy shows that PrP106-126 progressively decreases the orientational order of lipid acyl chains in magnetically aligned bicelles. Together, our experimental data support the proposition that monomeric PrP106-126 can disrupt lipid membranes by using similar mechanisms found in AMPs.