Due to the lack of precise markers indicative of its occurrence and progression, coronary artery disease (CAD), the most common type of heart diseases, is currently associated with high mortality in the United States. To systemically identify novel protein biomarkers associated with CAD progression for early diagnosis and possible therapeutic intervention, we employed an iTRAQ-based quantitative proteomic approach to analyze the proteome changes in the plasma collected from a pair of wild type versus apolipoprotein E knockout (APOE −/−) mice which were fed with a high fat diet. In a multiplex manner ITRAQ serves as the quantitative ‘in-spectra’ marker for ‘cross-sample’ comparisons to determine the differentially expressed/secreted proteins caused by APOE knock-out. To obtain the most comprehensive proteomic datasets from this CAD-associated mouse model we applied both MALDI and ESI-based mass spectrometric (MS) platforms coupled with two different schemes of multidimensional liquid chromatography (2D-LC) separation. We then comparatively analyzed a series of the plasma samples collected at six and twelve weeks after the mice were fed with fat diets, where the 6-week or 12-week time point represents the early or intermediate phase of the fat-induced CAD, respectively. We then categorized those proteins showing abundance changes in accordance with APOE depletion. Several proteins such as the gamma and beta chains of fibrinogen, apolipoprotein B, apolipoprotein C-I, and thrombospondin-4 were among the previously known CAD markers identified by other methods. Our results suggested that these unbiased proteomic methods are both feasible and a practical means of discovering potential biomarkers associated with CAD progression.