Beach wrack is an important supplier of nutrients and organic matter to sandy beach ecosystems and underlying subterranean estuaries (STEs), producing metabolic hotspots in these otherwise organic carbon- and nutrient-poor environments. To assess the impact of beach wrack type (e.g., marine, terrestrial, plant, animal) and environmental settings (e.g., tidal inundation, precipitation, and solar irradiation) on nutrient and dissolved organic matter (DOM) release, a series of leaching experiments was conducted. Quantities of leached nutrients and dissolved organic carbon (DOC) were determined, and DOM molecular composition was investigated using Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR-MS). Millimolar—to molar amounts of DOC and dissolved nitrogen were released from the beach cast per kg dry weight, with type of wrack and leaching medium (fresh- vs. saltwater) exerting the biggest influences. Exemplary for animal cast, jellyfish leached up to two 100-fold more, mostly organic, nitrogen compared to all other beach wrack types. FT-ICR-MS data of solid-phase extracted DOM indicated that beach wrack releases compounds with putative mono- and oligosaccharide-, amino acid- and vitamin-type molecular formulae, which likely serve as valuable substrate for heterotrophic microorganisms. DOM from the brown seaweed Fucus sp. was more aromatic than seawater DOM and even beach wrack of terrestrial origin, probably from structural components and secondary metabolites such as phlorotannins. We conclude that DOM and nutrient release from beach wrack strongly depends on wrack type and leaching medium, may obscure molecular provenance proxies (e.g., terrestrial indices), and adds a nutritional boost to infiltrating sea- and rainwater which likely impact microbial respiration rates in the STE.