The
development of efficient, stable, and economic water oxidation
catalysts (WOCs) is a forefront topic of sustainable energy research.
We newly present a comprehensive three-step approach to systematically
investigate challenging relationships among preparative history, properties,
and performance in heterogeneous WOCs. To this end, we studied (1)
the influence of the preparative method on the material properties
and (2) their correlation with the performance as (3) a function of
the catalytic test method. Spinel-type Co3O4 was selected as a clear-cut model WOC and synthesized via nine different
preparative routes. In search of the key material properties for high
catalytic performance, these cobalt oxide samples were characterized
with a wide range of analytical methods, including X-ray absorption
spectroscopy, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, powder X-ray diffraction,
Raman spectroscopy, BET surface area analysis, and transmission electron
microscopy. Next, the corresponding catalytic water oxidation activities
were assessed with the three most widely applied protocols to date,
namely, photocatalytic, electrocatalytic, and chemical oxidation.
The activity of the Co3O4 samples was found
to clearly depend on the applied test method. Increasing surface area
and disorder as well as a decrease in oxidation states arising from
low synthesis temperatures were identified as key parameters for high
chemical oxidation activity. Surprisingly, no obvious property–performance
correlations were found for photocatalytic water oxidation. In sharp
contrast, all samples showed similar activity in electrochemical water
oxidation. The substantial performance differences between the applied
protocols demonstrate that control and comprehensive understanding
of the preparative history are crucial for establishing reliable structure–performance
relationships in WOC design.