Moral and exhausting distress working in the frontline of COVID-19: a Swedish survey during the first wave in four healthcare settings

Abstract

ObjectivesTo describe the prevalence and sources of experienced moral stress and anxiety by Swedish frontline healthcare staff in the early phase of COVID-19.DesignCross-sectional survey, quantitative and qualitative.Participants and setting1074 healthcare professionals (75% nurses) in intensive, ward-based, primary and municipal care in one Swedish county.MeasuresA study-specific closed-ended and an open-ended questionnaire about moral stress and the Generalised Anxiety Disorder 7-item scale measuring anxiety, followed by an open question about anxiety.FindingsMoral stress was experienced by 52% of respondents and anxiety by 40%. Moral stress in concern for others attributed to institutional constraints comprised experiences of being deprived of possibilities to respond to humane and professional responsibility. Staff experienced being restricted in fulfilling patients’ and families’ need for closeness and security as well as being compelled to provide substandard and inhumane care. Uncertainty about right and good, without blame, was also described. However, a burdensome guilt also emerged as a moral distress, blaming oneself. This comprised feeling complicit in the spread of COVID-19, inadequacy in care and carrying patients’ suffering. Staff also experienced an exhausting distress as a self-concern in an uncontrollable work situation. This comprised a taxing insecurity by being in limbo, being alone and fear of failing, despair of being deprived control by not being heard; unable to influence; distrusting management; as well as an excessive workload.ConclusionsWe have not only contributed with knowledge about experiences of being in the frontline of COVID-19, but also with an understanding of a demarcation between moral stress/distress as a concern for patients and family, and exhausting distress in work situation as self-concern. A lesson for management is that ethics support should first include acknowledgement of self-concern and mitigation of guilt before any structured ethical reflection. Preventive measures for major events should focus on connectedness between all parties concerned, preventing inhumane care and burn-out.

Exploring healthcare workers’ experiences of a simple intervention to reduce their intrusive memories of psychological trauma: an interpretative phenomenological analysis

“…Repeated instances of traumatic events may, together with the increased workload, the lack of support, and the inability to provide good care (i.e. ethical stress; see Svantesson et al, 2022 ), have exacerbated the stress and duress under which HCWs were placed. Moreover, a conflict presents itself when an HCW, who has a profession known to help people, is unable to fulfil this exact purpose.…”

Effects of work-family conflict on turnover intention among primary medical staff in Huaihai Economic Zone: a mediation model through burnout

“…Although there had been studies exploring the relationship between turnover intention, burnout, and work-family conflict, there was limited research literature on the three factors mentioned above among primary medical staff, and there was even more limited research on the role of burnout in the relationship between work-family conflict and turnover intention ( 41 – 45 ). Therefore, attention needs to be paid to work-family conflict, burnout, and turnover intention among primary medical staff ( 46 – 48 ).…”

COVID-19- related work, managerial factors and exhaustion among general practitioners in Sweden: a cross-sectional study

“…In addition, moral distress and emotional demands contributed to burnout [ 28 , 29 , 31 – 33 ]. Healthcare professionals felt moral distress when they could not provide the desired patient care due to lack of resources [ 34 ]. They felt alone in making critical decisions about which patients should be given access to medical resources [ 24 , 35 ].…”