Moriarty’s Ghost

Abstract

This article argues that the BBC’s Sherlock is outwardly a conservative text sedimenting the historical function of Sherlock Holmes as a model of hegemonic British masculinity. However, queer disruptions in the performance of masculinity may be read as, after Butler, destabilizing and revealing the groundlessness of gender constructions. For as Butler has argued, hetero-masculine performativity is “constantly haunted by that domain of sexual possibility that must be excluded for heterosexualized gender to produce itself.” Referencing Laclau’s perception of “hauntologies” to texts (adapted from Derrida), I posit that the presence/specter of the queer villain Moriarty can be read as a caesura challenging performed hegemonic masculinity. With the possible death and promise of Moriarty’s return at the close of the current season, the series now stands at a crossroads. It may either revert to the queerbaiting of previous seasons or foreshadow a more radical text.

Online fandom communities as networked counterpublics: LGBTQ+ youths’ perceptions of representation and community climate

“…Lastly, another significant problem that persists in mass media is queerbaiting , a marketing technique to draw in LGBTQ+ audiences through implying a LGBTQ+ identity or relationship that is never unambiguously depicted (Fathallah, 2015). Queerbaiting can be performed by any number of actors attempting to profit from LGBTQ+ consumers, from individuals to large corporations (Brennan, 2019).…”

Digital Mobility and Cultural Consumption: Online Reception of Contemporary British Television Dramas in China

“…Sherlock has been accused of queerbaiting with its multiple "gay scenes" between Sherlock and Watson throughout the four series (Fathallah, 2014;Anselmo, 2018). The writer and showrunner of Sherlock, Steven Moffat has denied that queer-baiting strategies were used in the series on several occasions.…”