After a review of Arthur Benton's conceptual and methodological contributions to the understanding of normal and pathological development, we discuss agenesis of the corpus callosum (CC), criteria for potential neuroanatomical compensatory mechanisms in CC agenesis, and the results of an examination of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) data of the CC in 193 children with spina bifida meningomyelocele (SBM). There were 26 CC regional patterns. Although complete agenesis did not occur, partial agenesis was observed in 102 children and within 15 CC regional patterns. Only 4.1% had a normal CC. Quantitative assessment of the area of the CC in 26 NC children and 68 children with SBM revealed that all subgroups with CC anomalies had smaller areas than did a subgroup with a normal CC. Areas were especially small in rostral/splenial agenesis and splenial agenesis but larger with rostral agenesis. Subgroups with normal/hypoplastic regions or complete hypoplasia also had CC areas that were smaller than normal but larger than the areas for the splenial agenesis groups. The relative rarity of anterior commissure enlargement (3.1%) and longitudinal bundles of Probst (0.1%) suggest that these particular fiber tract anomalies are unlikely candidates for structural compensatory mechanisms. The hippocampal commissure, enlarged in 13%, may be a more promising candidate. Overall, however, the functionality of anomalous fiber tracts and commissures in SBM is yet to be determined.
KeywordsSpinal dysraphism; Magnetic resonance imaging; Anterior commissure; Neural tube defect; Plasticity This paper pays brief tribute to Arthur Benton's contributions to understanding both normal and pathological development of neurocognitive functions. It then develops some of the themes and methods in his work into an investigation of a contemporary developmental question: options for neuroanatomical functionality after congenital absence (partial agenesis) or thinning (hypoplasia) of regions of the great cerebral commissure, the corpus callosum (CC).
© 2008 Psychology PressAddress correspondence to H. Julia Hannay, Department of Psychology, Heyne Building, University of Houston, 4800 Calhoun, Houston, TX 77204-5052, USA (E-mail: E-mail: jhannay@uh.edu)..
NIH Public Access
BENTON'S CONTRIBUTIONS TO NORMAL AND PATHOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTArthur Benton's career was unique in a number of ways, not the least of which was his broad view of normal and pathological development. The biographical notes for his American Psychological Association Distinguished Professional Contribution Award for 1978 (American Psychological Association, 1979) indicate that he studied adults with brain injury at the Neurological Institute of New York (1935) and children with cerebral palsy for the Kentucky Crippled Children's Commission (1946). Review of his publications reveals papers on typical child function (e.g., normal children and the Visual Retention Test; Benton & Collins, 1949); typical adult function (e.g., young adults and the Block Design Test; Benton, 1941); a...