Mother knows best: maternal egg-clutch size predicts larval group size in pine sawflies (genusNeodiprion)

Abstract

Evolutionary conflicts are pervasive in nature and have the potential to drive antagonistic coevolution of conflict-related traits. However, when such conflicts are weak or idiosyncratic, phenotypic signatures of coevolutionary arms races may be absent. Here, we ask whether variation in group-living traits among pine-sawfly species in the genus Neodiprion is consistent with a history of parent-offspring conflict. To address this question, we compile data on adult female clutch size, larval aggregation behavior, and larval group size for a monophyletic group of 19 eastern North American Neodiprion species from field observations, laboratory assays, and published descriptions. We then evaluate the extent to which each trait exhibits phylogenetic signal and, based on these results, examine correlations between group-size traits both with and without phylogenetic correction. Although female oviposition behavior and larval grouping behavior varies among species and variation in these traits is decoupled from phylogeny, we find no evidence of antagonistic coevolution between these traits. Furthermore, while larvae are physically capable of dispersal, female clutch size is a strong predictor of larval colony size, indicating that larvae do not substantially alter initial group size after hatching. Thus, although theoretical work demonstrates the potential for parent-offspring conflict over group size in animals that lack parental care, our data suggest that this type of conflict is not likely to be a long-term driver of phenotypic evolution.