Motivated Innumeracy: Estimating the Size of the Gun Owner Population and Its Consequences for Opposition to Gun Restrictions

Abstract

Past research suggests that people substantially overestimate the size of minority populations. Labeled “innumeracy,” inflated estimates of minority populations can have a negative impact on intergroup relations and influence policy attitudes toward minority groups. Our research examines people’s estimates of the gun owner population in the United States. We discover that people vastly overestimate gun ownership and similarly misjudge its future growth. Estimations of size are influenced by several determinants including gun ownership and affective orientations toward gun owners. Gun owners, compared to nongun owners, reported higher estimations of the gun owner population. In addition, positive feelings toward gun owners were associated with increased estimates of gun ownership. Affective orientations toward minority populations are in fact a key predictor neglected by prior innumeracy studies. Finally, estimations of the gun owner population, and judgments about its future growth, were both significant determinants of gun policy preferences. Related Articles Related Media Pew Research Center. . “Gun Ownership Trends and Demographics.” https://www.people-press.org/2013/03/12/section-3-gun-ownership-trends-and-demographics/ Tom W.Smith and JaesokSon. . “General Social Survey Final Report: Trends in Gun Ownership in the United States, 1972‐2014..” NORC at the University of Chicago. https://www.norc.org/PDFs/GSS%20Reports/GSS_Trends%20in%20Gun%20Ownership_US_1972-2014.pdf

Voting on gun rights: Mapping the electoral scope of the pro‐gun constituency in America

“…In addition, behind that conceptual thicket lies the intractable problem of trying to specify the size of the gun‐owning population, let alone gauge the level of support for gun rights among the general public. Estimates of gun ownership vary widely and are influenced by whether the estimates are made by gun owners or non‐gun owners or by people with any number of demographic attributes (Joslyn and Haider‐Markel 2018).…”

Guns in the North: Assessing the Impact of Social Identity on Firearms Advocacy in Canada

“…2019; Spitzer 2015). They have posited that the gun culture, and the social identity that it cultivates, can serve as motivators for gun owners to remain politically active (Joslyn 2020; Joslyn and Haider‐Markel 2018; Lacombe 2019; Lacombe, Howat, and Rothschild 2019).…”

Can citizens guess how other citizens voted based on demographic characteristics?

“…In general, survey respondents struggle with questions that ask for shares of groups in the population (e.g. Joslyn and Haider-Markel, 2018;Kunovich, 2017). Mistakes in reporting probabilities can take the form of overly extreme probabilities (e.g.…”