Responding to calls for centering Black lives in our collective consciousness, this review uses Critical Race Theory to analyze researchers’ inclusion of race in conceptualizing and operationalizing adolescent reading motivation. Two questions guide this review: (1) How do researchers include race in theories of adolescent reading motivation? and (2) What assumptions do researchers make about race in studying adolescent reading motivation? What conclusions do they draw based on these assumptions? Through a systematic search, articles addressing adolescent reading motivation’s conceptual/theoretical foundations, measurement, and study as it relates to reading behaviors and outcomes were identified and analyzed using deductive thematic analysis. Findings emerged across three categories: (1) color‐evasiveness, demonstrating reading motivation was not conceptualized with Black readers in mind, (2) modus operandi, showing business‐as‐usual approaches to studying reading motivation, and (3) difference and deficit, illustrating how researchers have positioned Black readers in comparison to their white counterparts. Recommendations are made for how adolescent reading motivation can be reimagined to center Black readers’ histories, experiences, and brilliance.