(3,4). Before these immature cells leave the bone marrow for the periphery, it has been shown, they undergo several types of negative selection to avoid autoreactivity. These processes, including clonal deletion (5), receptor editing (6, 7), and clonal anergy (8), are thought to be largely complete before the exit of these cells into the periphery, where a fraction of them subsequently differentiate into mature B cells (Hardy fraction F) (9, 10), which are surface IgM int , IgD hi , B220 hi , HSA int (4). Seventy percent of peripheral immature B cells that bear functional surface IgM (fraction E) do not survive to maturity (fraction F), although the nature of the process that causes this cell loss is unknown (3). This cell loss either could occur by a stochastic process in which cell fate is determined without regard to the specificity of the BCR or could occur by a selective process in which the specificity of the BCR determines which cells can survive.To better understand the selective processes that determine which immature B cells survive to comprise the mature BCR repertoire, we examined the BCR repertoire of immature peripheral B cells and compared it to the BCR repertoire of mature peripheral B cells. A stochastic process would predict identical BCR repertoires in the immature and mature B cell populations; a selective process would be reflected by substantial differences between the two repertoires. We find that there is indeed significant selection of the BCR repertoire at the immature to mature conventional B cell transition in the periphery of the mouse. The nature of this selection is most indicative of positive selection of certain cells that comprise a small fraction of the BCR repertoire.
Materials and MethodsMice. Heavy chain transgenic mice of Meg and Daisy line were constructed as described (11) -biotin antibody (PharMingen). All biotinylated antibodies were revealed with streptavidin-Texas Red. Additional staining with anti-B7.2-biotin (clone GL1) (12), rat anti-mouse-CD1d purified antibody (PharMingen) followed by a goat anti-rat-IgG-biotin secondary (Kirkegaard & Perry Laboratories), anti-CD5 (clone 53.7), and anti-CD44 (clone PgP-1) (11) was performed to assess surface expression of these markers. PCR Amplification. Genomic DNA was extracted with the DNAzol reagent (GIBCO͞BRL) and was amplified by using a degenerate V consensus primer (13) and one of two J 2 intronic primers. The internal J 2 primer (14) was utilized for the first Meg line mouse and all three Daisy line mice analyzed. An external J 2 primer, TCCCTCCTTAACACCTGATCTGAGAATGG, was used for the analysis of the second two Meg line mice and the wild-type control mouse. PCR conditions were 28 cycles of 94°C for 30 sec, 60°C for 90 sec, and 72°C for 60 sec, with a 5-sec extension per cycle (14).Cloning and Sequencing. Consensus V -J 2 PCR products (Ϸ190 bp for the internal J 2 primer and Ϸ300 bp for the external J 2 Abbreviation: BCR, B cell receptor.