Moving Toward Person-Centered Care: Valuing Emotions in Hospital Design and Architecture

Abstract

The intangible value of emotions is often neglected in healthcare evaluations; however, it forms an important part of the hospital experience that needs to be taken into consideration to move toward person-centered care. This article conceptualizes how space and architecture may influence patient, family, and healthcare provider emotions. Building upon Gaston Bachelard’s Poetics of Space, theories on emotional design and architecture, as well as research in environmental design, we suggest several ways to value emotions in hospital design and architecture. The first theme explores several hospital spaces (the waiting room, the hospital room, the treatment room) using Bachelard’s phenomenology in order to show how to facilitate emotional security by catering to the individual needs of the user. The second discusses the overall hospital room environment, notably the influence of light, color, and sound on the patient’s emotional experience. The third explores architectural theorist Giuliana Bruno’s theory of e(motion) to explore the hospital space as vissuto, a space of lived experiences, that invites us to rethink the design and architecture of hospital spaces to allow for patient participation. The article also gives suggestions of qualitative, person-centered methodologies that can be used to move forward this debate.

An Orthopedic Healthcare Facility Governance Assessed with a New Indicator System

“…Hospital design requires combining the patient’s perceptions and expectations of the physical environment in the care area. Space and architecture influence the emotions of the patient and his relatives, as well as the providers of medical services [ 31 ].…”

Neuroarchitecture: How the Perception of Our Surroundings Impacts the Brain

“…This effect, which is frequently instinctive and unconscious, emphasizes the close relationship between architectural environments and human emotions. Furthermore, historical references that date back to French architectural theorists of the eighteenth century have highlighted the idea that architecture has the ability to connect to people's minds and souls [46].…”

Designing positive emotional experiences of wearable medical technology for type 1 diabetes

“…More recently Lim et al's 2020 model included cognition, emotion, social and value themes as key determining factors in what they term psychosocially inclusive design, improving quality of life for as many as possible in terms of social and psychological factors. Similarly, person-centred care has been suggested as a new perspective on healthcare (Bogaert, 2022), considering the patient and other stakeholders as partners in their own medical treatment, mirroring human centred design principles (Giacomin, 2014;Weatherly & Reay 2022;Vougioukalou et al, 2019). However, Yang et al (2021) states that human centred design often favours cognition over emotional factors despite emotion's growing importance in healthcare (Yoon et al, 2020;Niedenthal & Ric, 2017;Mugge et al, 2008), hence the need for an improved perspective.…”

“…In recent years wearable technology has shown promise in solving this issue (Low & Ramayah, 2023;Zeng et al, 2022;Ferreira et al, 2021) reducing hospitalisations and enabling self-monitoring (Wang et al, 2020). However, Wang et al identify a lack of consumer acceptance, with 30% of wearables being abandoned, in part due a focus on efficiency, low cost and clinical needs as key factors in the design of medical devices, using a disease model of design (Bogaert, 2022;Weatherly & Reay, 2022;Yoon et al, 2020;Pullin, 2009). Medical design and design for disability encounter sensitive issues, having a major effect on a user's self-image and emotions (Kim & Ho, 2021;Yang et al, 2021;Pullin, 2009) however, traditionally medical design is conducted by clinical engineers in an isolated laboratory, distanced from the real world (Hall & Lobo, 2018).…”