Much Ado About Nothing? Do Foreign Domestic Workers in Hong Kong Benefit From Capital Accumulation?

Abstract

The accumulation of human and social capital plays a significant role in influencing migrants’ earnings and economic integration in the host society. Although the effects of foreign domestic workers’ bargaining power on their labor market outcome is constrained due to their unique migrant status, domestic workers may still strive to make use of various resources to secure “ideal” jobs as much as possible. Using a randomly selected unique data set collected in Hong Kong in 2017, this study examines whether foreign domestic workers’ human and social capitals are associated with their salary scale, working conditions, and work rights protection. We use education, previously held jobs, migration duration, and language proficiency to measure human capital, and friendship networks and church attendance to indicate social capital. We found that previously having middle-level job experience can reduce the likelihood of experiencing underpay and increase the likelihood of having overpay, taking the legal minimum salary as a reference. English language proficiency could also give them some leverage to access a better pay scale. Previous human capital accumulation is associated with having a private room in the employer’s home. It is also associated with better protection of work rights such as being less likely to experience a “no pay” month. For social capital, frequent participation in Sunday gathering with friends is mainly associated with rights protection. These findings indicate that although foreign domestic workers may be constrained in using their capital accumulation to improve their market value substantially, the capital accumulation can still give some leverage for them to bargain for a slightly improved salary, better working conditions, and protection of their rights.

Physical and Mental Health of Live-In Female Migrant Domestic Workers: A Randomly Sampled Survey in Hong Kong

“…Moreover, since our study was cross-sectional, the negative association may represent a case of reversed causality—that is, those who have worse mental health depend more on the social support that religious activities can give them. The formal and informal social support systems of MDWs have been further explored in Baig and Chang (2020), while the effect on protection of rights of the social capital associated with their social network and activities have been explored by Tong (2020).…”

Better a Friend Nearby Than a Brother Far Away? The Health Implications of Foreign Domestic Workers’ Family and Friendship Networks

“…Modern technology such as mobile phones and Internet devices has made it much easier for FDWs to stay in touch with loved ones back in their home countries. Sunday gatherings with other FDWs also offer a source of comfort and emotional support, as well as promoting work rights protection (Tong & Jiang, 2020). Because of the nature of their employment, they live in the employer’s home, so the ties with the employer could have health implications as well.…”

Differentiation from above and below: Evolving immigration policy and the integration dilemma in Singapore

“…They cannot bring family members, cannot easily change employers, and have no pathways to permanent settlement. These regulations are particularly strict in migrant-receiving countries in Asia as compared with Western liberal democracies (Castles et al, 2014; Cook-Martin, 2019; Stasiulis, 2008; Tong and Jiang, 2020).…”