Multi-symptom asthma as an indication of disease severity in epidemiology

Abstract

Epidemiological questionnaires have failed to identify individuals with severe asthma. The extent of symptoms of asthma can, however, be easily established in epidemiology, by identification of multiple symptoms. We hypothesise that reporting of multiple symptoms of asthma reflects uncontrolled disease and is a sign of more severe asthma. The aims of the current study were, therefore, to determine the prevalence and determinants of multi-symptom asthma.A postal questionnaire was sent to 30,000 randomly selected individuals aged 16-75 yrs. A subgroup underwent clinical examinations. Multi-symptom asthma was defined as reported physician-diagnosed asthma, use of asthma medication, recurrent wheeze, attacks of shortness of breath and at least one additional respiratory symptom.The prevalence of multi-symptom asthma was 2.0%, and it was more common among females (2.4 versus 1.5%; p,0.001) and those with a body mass index .30 kg?m -2 . Multi-symptom asthmatics had lower forced expiratory volume in 1 s, higher exhaled nitric oxide fraction and more pronounced hyperresponsiveness. Family history of both asthma and allergy (OR 7.3), and occupational exposure to gas dust or fumes (OR 2.0) were also significant risk factors. Multi-symptom asthmatics comprise 2% of the general population; multi-symptom asthma is related to signs of more severe disease and could be used as an epidemiological marker of disease severity.

Aspirin‐intolerant asthma in the population: prevalence and important determinants

“…Severity of asthma is difficult to measure in epidemiologic studies. However, the burden of respiratory symptoms may serve as a proxy for disease severity [20]. We found a higher prevalence of a large number of respiratory symptoms in AIA than in ATA.…”

Eczema among adults: prevalence, risk factors and relation to airway diseases. Results from a large-scale population survey in Sweden

“…Definitions of respiratory symptoms and exposure have been described in previous publications 19,25 . Severe asthma was defined as multisymptom asthma using a composite definition 26 . Further definitions included: growing up on a farm, ‘Did you live on a farm during your first 5 years of life?’ Family history of allergy, ‘Has any of your parents or siblings ever had allergic eye or nose problems (hay fever)?’ Family history of asthma, ‘Has any of your parents or siblings ever had asthma?’ Exposure to gas, dust or fumes at work, ‘Have you been substantially exposed to dust, gases or fumes at work?’…”

Severe asthma: from characteristics to phenotypes to endotypes

“…These characteristics include things like degree of bronchodilator responsiveness and persistent airflow limitation, presence/absence of atopy/allergy, obesity and inflammatory characteristics such as eosinophilia and neutrophilia. In addition, two recent large studies from the West Sweden Asthma Study suggest that rhinosinusitis and its symptoms, occupational exposures to gas, dust, fumes, smoking history and family histories of allergy/asthma, as well as female gender and old age are all characteristics, and in many cases, risk factors for multi‐symptom asthma (as a surrogate for more ‘severe’ asthma . Clinical, cluster and genetic studies are also suggesting that the characteristic of age at onset, when dividing between childhood and adult onset disease is a discriminatory characteristic .…”