Multi-year optimization of malaria intervention: a mathematical model

Abstract

BackgroundMalaria is a mosquito-borne, lethal disease that affects millions and kills hundreds of thousands of people each year, mostly children. There is an increasing need for models of malaria control. In this paper, a model is developed for allocating malaria interventions across geographic regions and time, subject to budget constraints, with the aim of minimizing the number of person-days of malaria infection.MethodsThe model considers a range of several conditions: climatic characteristics, treatment efficacy, distribution costs, and treatment coverage. An expanded susceptible-infected-recovered compartment model for the disease dynamics is coupled with an integer linear programming model for selecting the disease interventions. The model produces an intervention plan for all regions, identifying which combination of interventions, with which level of coverage, to use in each region and year in a 5-year planning horizon.ResultsSimulations using the model yield high-level, qualitative insights on optimal intervention policies: The optimal intervention policy is different when considering a 5-year time horizon than when considering only a single year, due to the effects that interventions have on the disease transmission dynamics. The vaccine intervention is rarely selected, except if its assumed cost is significantly lower than that predicted in the literature. Increasing the available budget causes the number of person-days of malaria infection to decrease linearly up to a point, after which the benefit of increased budget starts to taper. The optimal policy is highly dependent on assumptions about mosquito density, selecting different interventions for wet climates with high density than for dry climates with low density, and the interventions are found to be less effective at controlling malaria in the wet climates when attainable intervention coverage is 60 % or lower. However, when intervention coverage of 80 % is attainable, then malaria prevalence drops quickly in all geographic regions, even when factoring in the greater expense of the higher coverage against a constant budget.ConclusionsThe model provides a qualitative decision-making tool to weigh alternatives and guide malaria eradication efforts. A one-size-fits-all campaign is found not to be cost-effective; it is better to consider geographic variations and changes in malaria transmission over time when determining intervention strategies.

An Adaptive Intervention Trial Design for Finding the Optimal Integrated Strategies for Malaria Control and Elimination in Africa: A Model Simulation Study

“…There is substantial literature on the cost and cost-effectiveness of malaria interventions. 21,45,75,76 Previous cost-effectiveness analysis has focused primarily on individual interventions; the cost-effectiveness of an integrated vector management program has not been thoroughly evaluated. Adding more interventions on top of existing interventions may further reduce disease transmission, but it may also increase material and operational costs.…”

Modeling the impact of Malakit intervention: one more step towards malaria elimination in the Guiana Shield?

“…We developed a deterministic Susceptible-Infectious-Susceptible (SIS) compartmental model to simulate the transmission of malaria in a single population encompassing all individuals living in illegal gold mining sites in French Guiana. We used a human-to-human transmission rate which accounted for the vector population dynamics (12)(13)(14) with a seasonal forcing defined as an exponential effect of maximum daily temperature, with a lag. In our model, the infected population (I) corresponded to individuals with a detectable parasite density in PCR and was distributed into four model compartments: asymptomatic (IA), symptomatic but not (or incompletely) treated (IS) and symptomatic treated either by the health system (IT) or with the use of a malakit (IM).…”

Evaluating the Effectiveness of Potential Interventions for Guinea Worm Disease in Dogs in Chad Using Simulations

“…Computer simulation models have been used for modeling the epidemiology of influenza, 3,4 HIV/AIDS, 5 and malaria. 6,7 Perini et al 8 presented a stochastic agent-based simulation model capturing the natural transmission pathway(s) of GW infections in dogs in Chad. The model accounted for environment-driven seasonality, an important factor in GW transmission 9,10 and was validated using integrated national data provided by the Chad Guinea Worm Eradication Program (GWEP).…”