Multicultural Hong Kong: alternative new media representations of ethnic minorities

Abstract

Racial and ethnic minorities experience misrecognition, prejudice, and discimination in Hong Kong. In response to these challenges, multicultural education there aims to enable young people to recognize diversity in a more tolerant, open-minded way. Educators have been encouraged to not rely only on textbooks, but to include news and digital media in such teaching. This paper examines online media representations of diversity in Hong Kong in the context of multicultural education, focusing on Apple Daily (AD), a popular liberal Hong Kong news source. We analyze how AD represents ethnic minorities, contributing to the construction of a particular multicultural environment and identity among Hong Kong people. Despite its multicultural orientation, AD remains problematic as a learning tool. In relation we recommend that more alternative digital media be used to learn about diversity in Hong Kong. We give as an example the use of student self-authored digital texts during the Hong Kong Umbrella Movement, which enabled ethnic minorities to engage in performative citizenship. We identify a focus on multiple, self-authored perspectives as part of critical media literacy, which we regard as essential for young people to better understand diversity, in contrast to straightforward reliance on multicultural news sources.

Perspectives towards cultural competence and receptivity to cultural competence training: a qualitative study on healthcare professionals

“…The final recommendation concerns wider social changes via community education. Ethnoculturally diverse groups are not always portrayed positively in mainstream media and public discourses in societies (Ahmed and Matthes, 2017), including in Hong Kong (Sung, 2005;Erni and Leung, 2014;Jackson and Nesterova, 2017). Prevailing social mindsets and perceptions about ethnoculturally diverse groups, including stereotypes of and bias towards 'ethnic minorities', may influence healthcare professionals' ideas about cultural competence training.…”

Support from service agency and resilience of ethnic minorities: the case of Nepalese communities in Hong Kong in COVID-19

“…Testing strength-based social work practices Hong Kong EM are phenotypically visible; they are socially invisible (Chee, 2017). The voices of EM are not represented in media or other public discourses; even with minor occurrences, they shed a negative light (Jackson and Nesterova, 2017). Moreover, Hong Kong's focus on meritocracy and sinicization enhances the inequalities (hence vulnerabilities) in EMs.…”

Media, Allegiance and Civic Education

“…Mainstream news in Hong Kong describes how "expat brats" will grow into maladjusted adults due to cultural differences between westerners and Chinese people (Wordie, 2015). Another article charges that "in Hong Kong, integration of expatriate children is only skin-deep", as they are identified (Mughal, 2015) as essentially connected to the British colonial legacy (see also Jackson & Nesterova, 2017). An emphasis on the border between civilizations as problematic, where there are clashes, can be found in Arab news sources (e.g., Kantaria, 2016).…”

“…Thus, local and localist media can be seen to reflect those values as the essentially local values or the appropriate values to hold locally. In localist news coverage of ethnic minority issues in a society, one might find that more attention is paid to the perspectives of those in the mainstream ethnic group, for example, over the voices of ethnic minorities, thereby disadvantaging those groups in gaining equitable representation in media (Nesterova & Jackson, 2017). Who gets attention and who does not, and which perspectives are favoured, are critical questions to consider in promoting localist agendas in media.…”