Multilateralism, Bilateralism and Institutional Choice: The Political Economy of Regime Complexes in International Trade Policy

Abstract

The global trading regime is characterized by the co‐existence of bilateral and multilateral politics. In this article, we offer a political economy explanation for this regime complex, by tracing public actors’ institutional choices back to political incentives for economic sectors and the firms active within them. First, we argue that product differentiation creates mixed motives on the part of firms, which in turn leads to a preference for the segmentation of markets, and thus bilateralism. Second, we contend that among these firms, multinational corporations (MNCs) are particularly well‐positioned to exert influence over policy decisions in multiple international fora, both bilateral and multilateral. This provides incentives for multinationals to push governments to create and sustain regime complexes in the form of nested regimes. We show how these expectations are largely born out in an empirical test for six different economic sectors.

Metatheoretical Issues of the Evolution of the International Political Economy

“…Despite the scientific value of elaborating the methodological problems of world economic system evolution (Amin 1996;Cotula 2012;Cyfert et al 2021;Dalevska et al 2019;Dossani and Kenney 2007;Dasgupta et al 2021;De Bièvre and van Ommeren 2021;Dzwigol 2021;Galiani et al 2019;Garrett 2006;Geels 2005;Elbahnasawy and Ellis 2022;Elbe and Long 2020;Fuchs 2007;Gilpin 1987;Graham and Tucker 2019;Graz et al 2020;Hussain et al 2020Hussain et al , 2021Huang 2010;Fossung et al 2021;Keohane and Nye 1977;Kharazishvili et al 2020Kharazishvili et al , 2021aKharazishvili et al , 2021bKravchenko 2019;Kurowska-Pysz and Szczepa ńska-Woszczyna 2017;Kuzior et al 2020;Las Heras 2018;Levitt 1983;Marlin-Bennett and Johnson 2021;Medeiros 2021;McNally 2012;Nunn and Shields 2022;Paterson 2021;Postlewaite and Schmeidler 1986;Shkodina et al 2020;Simmons and Zachary 2004;Smith and White 1992;Smirnova et al 2021;Stiglitz 2002;…”